Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden II

I typically wear a size 7. Sometimes I am a 6 1/2. I bought a size, and they are just a tiny bit too big. It turns out this is a good thing though. The soles are hard and have no support. The extra space gave me room to add my own cushioning/support. Once I added the cushioning, they became comfortable enough. I am going to keep them. Personally, I think I paid too much for a pair of boots whose soles felt like standing on bricks.

Really excellent fit and wideth for my wide feet.

Cute boot and I needed this color. But it was quite short and narrow. I even sized up 1/2 a notch. If remotely comfortable I would have kept them. But this was a no go for me. They seem to be cutting shoes/boots smaller and narrower these days.

I ordered this in a wide and could not get my foot in it. I am an 8 in a tennis shoe and ordered the 8 wide. It looks like a 7 med. Ordered several brands not in wide and it was so much smaller

These look cute and are comfortable, but they are not warm. I wore them for a walk in 20-degree, weather and my feet were freezing.

This boot is very wide. Nice, but wide overall. Length was ok, just really roomy with no arch

Great fit! Comfortable. Good in snow, stayed warm

A bit narrow for my wool socks

I ordered a size 9 but got an 8. Way too small. Also the price increased, that is not acceptable!!;!+!

Nice looking. Strong build. Comfortable. Just what I needed

Too small, uncomfortable, and marginal quality for a Columbia product.

Good fit. Comfy.

Bought for trips to cold places, and these are great! Ordered a size bigger than normal, to fit thick socks!

The boot was not flexible.

I bought these in 8W black a few years ago. They still fit, they’re warm, my feet stay dry, comfortable to wear all day. I’m tempted to buy these in a different color too!