Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden II

Felt very cheap and not comfortable at all .

These boots are warm and perfect for being out in the cold. I did have to add inserts for better arch support.

Arch support is disappointing but not a deal breaker. The taller boots were out of stock so I got these mid height ones instead. They are lightweight, which is a plus, and fit well with any weight socks.

I normally wear an 8 but these were an 8 wide. They have no cushioning whatsoever and immediately hurt my feet. They're going back

Very flimsy material with NO INSULATION or cushioning. Returned. Columbia has become a trash brand. Zappos should vet theses companies.

Loving these boots for warmth, traction, ease of pulling on and off and style!

These boots are SO cute! I would have kept them except the side of the boot rubbed up against my ankle and irritated it.

I was barely able to get it on with no socks and I ordered a half size larger so I could wear heavier socks. Very sad! I needed new boots.

sizing was fine I have had 2 pair of these my others are very comfortable these are not they are hard inside not soft and comfy

Love the boots. They are sturdy and winter-weather worthy!

These boots felt like they would be warm, but the fit was not right for me to give them a try outside. There was very little cushioning and they just felt hard on the bottom of my feet. They were easy to put on and the height of the boot was mid calf.

I love these boots! Waterproof, snow proof, my feet are so warm! Great traction in the snow as well!

Comfortable and warm.

Cute boots. The sole feels hard and I was hoping for a more comfortable feel.

I bought these a little big to allow for thick socks or foot warmers, and they're great. Also adorable, and they're wide enough to accommodate my calves, which is fantastic.

I ordered a size 11 because 10.5 was not available, and I have an orthotic that I always use, which takes up extra room. Since I have narrow heels, the heels were slipping. In this case, there was too much slippage, and I had to return the boots. Overall, I loved the style and warmth of these boots.

Toe box was too small and my heel was slipping up and down even with orthotics. The materials were ok but a bit stiff.

I have terrible issues with shoes for my short and wide feet with bunions. Not a bad fit for a 7-5 wide but only with thin socks and no added liner for the sole of the foot to be warmer. So decided to go with 8W.

Lovely boot but insole flat and no arch support.

I wanted to like these boots. They look good but they don't feel soft or warm inside and they are too narrow for thick socks. Also, when you tighten them down the tongue gets bunched and is uncomfortable.