Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Athens Penny

I did buy these 1/2 size larger than my standard size, but these shoe were ultra comfortable for my first wear! I am bringing them with on an upcoming cruise to wear for informal dinners and can't wait until driving season in the car! I will order more in another color soon!

The shoes literally came delivered UPS ground in two days! The fit great. Lightweight and is just what I wanted. Thanks, Aso I felt it was a good value for the money.

we were looking for a classic but casual and comfortable shoe for more everyday wear. stumbled upon these (first JM purchase!) and my husband absolutely loves them! they're perfect style and he says they're very comfortable. easy to dress up or down!

I've received a number of compliments when wearing these. They fit well on my narrow foot, and feel comfortable throughout the day. I walk to/from my office so they're getting a lot of active steps. I'm glad I purchased multiple colors. These are already proving to be a summer/fall staple.

These loafers are comfortable and look great. I've only had them for a couple weeks so it's too soon to report on longevity but they seem very well-made. I normally take a 10 1/2 but had to downsize to 9 1/2 with these.

Excellent shoe, very high quality and the price is a super value Thanks

I've had a couple of pair of these style shoes over the years and they are great. Very versatile and comfortable.

I've using this brand for years and every single pair of boots and shoes I've bought has been excellent, high quality and design, long lasting footwear for prices, great quality of materials

They fit true to size. Great quality and feels very durable. Great casual loafer. The leather and stitching came in a little darker than I was expecting, but I'm sure it will all lighten up with time and use.

Love these drivers"they are super comfortable, pretty cushioned and supportive for a driver, and the blue suede looks fantastic. May have to pick up another pair in olive.

Great shoes, great style, great fit, easy to order.

Comfort and style is what to look for in a shoe. Though a little slim fit, they loosen up quickly. Blue suede shoes what else can be said. Oh, yeah for driving, they're GREAT!

Looks very nice, comfortable but run smaller

Run too tight. Color was not to satisfaction neither.

The shoe is strange, but you get used to it after a day of wear. Not a great Midwest winter daily-driver, but I'm looking forward to these in the summer. The fit is a bit tight, but not obscene.

Very comfortable if somewhat narrow

Gorgeous but a full size too small. No elastic gores, no stretch.

This shoe fits well and looks nice with jeans and causual slacks.

Love them! Great fit, comfy, and looks classy! Recommend. Fits true to size.

Incredible Shoe

Thankyou for constructing great shoes

This is my second pair of Johnston & Murphy Loafers and I am always happy to have them, they have a classic look that never feels old. These loafers pair really goid with a jeans or even with shorts and sometimes I wear them without socks for a relaxed look

Great style and comfortable. Highly recommend. Actually bought two pair

Its a nice driving moc, but I have pretty narrow feet and these were *way* too narrow for me. I cant imagine who they will fit.

Purchased for my nephew for his February 2025 birthday. Hopefully, all features will be good for him.