Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Athens Penny

This is a nice looking shoe for dressy casual look unfortunately it was to tight(narrow) so we had to return them. Would love to see the maid in a wider size

It has a perfect fit for my foot. I have a very sensitive foot and I always look for comfortable shoes and this was a true with with style and comfort.

Fit is true, materials are quality, right footed shoe sewing seem has a defect / lack of symmetry with the other. Minor and tolerable.

Enjoying these comfortable shoes. Glad I made the purchase

These shoes are very comfortable and stylish and I am most impressed with the sole of the shoe. Overall I would definitely purchase this shoe again

I surprised my son with these. He's going into college and I thought he needed a little boost to his footwear. He loves them bc they can be worn with a pair of jeans, shorts, semi dressy or toned down. Great staple to have in the wardrobe.

Loved the color.Feels like you are wearing a pair of slippers fits great definitely going to buy additional colors.

I bought it taupe and came in blue.

The shoes were exactly what they showed in the ad. It was a quick delivery. Easy transaction!

These are really great stylish comfortable shoes. Ideal for the summer weather.

Ive using this brand for years and every single pair of boots and shoes Ive bought has been excellent, high quality and design, long lasting footwear for prices, great quality of materials

Really good quality , true to size fit and stylish!

I recently purchases an updated wardrobe for myself and I am very pleased with everything. The 5 pocket pants are super comfortable, the shoes are true to size, and the shirts are stylish and comfortable.

They fit true to size. Great quality and feels very durable. Great casual loafer. The leather and stitching came in a little darker than I was expecting, but Im sure it will all lighten up with time and use.

Both my wife and I said "not too out-there" for the color. It's suede, not nubuck. Also runs narrow.

The shoes are beautiful and fit very well. I will look forward to many more wearings in the future.

Love the color

Love the shoes

These loafers look great but fit extremely narrow. I dont have wide feet but these styles are unwearable.

Love these driversthey are super comfortable, pretty cushioned and supportive for a driver, and the blue suede looks fantastic. May have to pick up another pair in olive.

Just as I thought they would look like and feel

TRIED ON IN STORE... COULD NOT GET ON EVEN WITH SHOE HORN. NEEDED WIDER SIZE THAN "MED" AS VERY DIFFICULT WITH SHOE HORN

It's a nice driving moc, but I have pretty narrow feet and these were *way* too narrow for me. I can't imagine who they will fit.

While I love the looks of these pennys, they were quite uncomfortable. Perhaps they require a break-in period but I didn't attempt to wear again. J&M makes returning so easy and I'm exchanging for a different type of shoe.

These loafers look great but fit extremely narrow. I don't have wide feet but these styles are unwearable.