Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Athens Penny

Sized much different than dress shoes .. same size didn't fit had to return

Nice look and fit. Could use a little more cushion

Nice looking shoes. I wear them casually without socks. They will be more comfortable once their broken in.

Length is good width is too narrow. Quality materials and workmanship a good looking shoe.

Bought these for my husband as he wanted a very comfortable casual shoe. These definitely fit the bill!

Great looking shoe, unfortunately, I had to send back because the shoe was too narrow for my foot. I wide width would work better for me, but would recommend to other people!

Beautiful color, nice style, but runs very narrow.

Firm leather, comfy

Ive received a number of compliments when wearing these. They fit well on my narrow foot, and feel comfortable throughout the day. I walk to/from my office so theyre getting a lot of active steps. Im glad I purchased multiple colors. These are already proving to be a summer/fall staple.

we were looking for a classic but casual and comfortable shoe for more everyday wear. stumbled upon these (first JM purchase!) and my husband absolutely loves them! theyre perfect style and he says theyre very comfortable. easy to dress up or down!

Very good looking shoe and very comfortable.

Perfect color year round, especially in the Fall. Has a sophiticated vibe about itself.

Great shoe for the money! Fit was perfect and material is good quality.

These loafers are comfortable and look great. Ive only had them for a couple weeks so its too soon to report on longevity but they seem very well-made. I normally take a 10 1/2 but had to downsize to 9 1/2 with these.

Exceptional service and customer satisfaction

Excellent shoe, very high quality and the price is a super value Thanks

I like to wear moccasins as it is the most comfortable type of shoes for me. But not this one. Unfortunately my wife bought it through internet and I didnt try it. And I weared it for one time and that is why cant return it. I dont know whose idea was to make a seam on the heel, but it is very unconfortable.

While I love the looks of these pennys, they were quite uncomfortable. Perhaps they require a break-in period but I didnt attempt to wear again. J&M makes returning so easy and Im exchanging for a different type of shoe.

I love J&Ms stuffespecially the shirts, shoes, and socks. The soles on these shoes are especially nice.

I love J&M's stuffespecially the shirts, shoes, and socks. The soles on these shoes are especially nice.

Ive had a couple of pair of these style shoes over the years and they are great. Very versatile and comfortable.

It is very comfy . Right size , right width

Very comfortable and high quality materials. I received multiple compliments wearing these around.

These shoes are comfortable. You can wear them dressed up or down.

Very comfortable but run a bit large. I added a heel pad and all is good. Gotten ton's of compliments.