Customer Reviews Calvin Klein Gayle

Very small toe box. These are cute but uncomfortable. Could not wear my typical size nor a 1/2 size up.

This is an OK shoe - looks kind of meh in person. If you are looking for a classic neutral shoe for work, then it will do. But if you like a little style there's not much special about this shoe. Also runs a little narrow.

I have these shoes in other colors, and I agree with another poster..they don't all fit the same. Maybe it's because one material is more firm than another? I do love the style and the heel height isn't too high.

These were not very comfortable. I have high arches and these provided no support. They were extremely tight in the toes. I could barely squeeze them in. It's safe to say they're a little on the narrow side and I have normal to narrow feet. Also, they give terrible toe cleavage (I hate toe cleavage). They are going back.

Very pretty looking...beautiful color. However, they are VERY small... and the front is too squished and shows off too much toe cleavage. Not attractive. Much return.

The shoes are a lot smaller than normal. I am not sure if I need half or a full size bigger, I guess I will found out. Other than that they are very nice quality.

This shoe is not uncomfortable, but I do not recommend the liquid brown patent color. It looks really cheap. It should be real leather for the price, not crinkled plastic.

These are absolutely gorgeous and really easy to walk in, but they are too tight in the toe box for me. Going up a size would have left my heel slipping out of the shoe, though, so no exchange for me.

Wanted these to work so bad(ly?), they are pretty shoes --- but ouch! I can't believe how many reviewers say how comfy these are, I did not have the same experience. I don't have a wide foot and usually am 9.5 but will sometimes go up to 10. Could barely get my foot into the 9.5 and although the 10 just fit lengthwise, my toes were so pinched by these! I also bought a cute pair of pointy toe 9.5 Cole Haan heels that were comfortable for hours, so these were just too narrow in the toe for me. As another reviewer said, if they offered this in a wide I would try it because they are so attractive.

I really wanted these shoes to work but they were just too narrow - I'm usually a 6 - 6.5 so when the 6 was too tight, I sized up and that fit everywhere except the width. I wouldn't say I have exceptionally narrow feet, but I also don't usually have to purchase W. They are really pretty though so if they had offered a wider size, I would have tried! Too bad.

Have Calvin Klein Dolly, was hoping for a similar fit with Gayle, but it was not comfortable at all, so returning. Pinched toes, not comfortable to walk in.

I think Nikki from Seattle means they run small!! She had to buy a larger size so they would fit comfortably; that means they run small for the size marked on the shoe. I had to do the same, otherwise they're lovely.

I wear a 7½M and found that the toe box is way too small. I have narrow to medium size feet. So I was surprised and will be returning them. The shoes are pretty.

I didn't realized that this shoe has a silver attachment above the heel. I need a conservative black heel and I am not sure why they choose to put the silver on the back on the shoe.

Omg these are one of favs! I have them four different colors . They are smart and transition from the office to after 5 beautifully…BUT who needs a shoe with sole that’s crumbles ??? Yikes ! If you are good with this then it’s a fab shoe if not then don’t buy this beauty of a shoe … so sad:(

Runs very small. Not quite as described. Disappointing.

On the never ending search for comfy pumps. I have some, I just can't seem to replace them. Why are all the shoes so uncomfortable these days?!?

I was SO disappointed with these. Finally treating myself and these were a nightmare. Super small for super small narrow feet

I wear a 7.5, and ordered that size first but it was way too small. I exchanged for an 8, because I loved how they looked, but was still too uncomfortable to keep. I wear heels almost everyday, and there was no way I could even make it out of the house in these, let alone work a full day in them! So sad, because they were so pretty..

It is a beautiful looking shoe, but quite small and narrow, requiring at least a half to full size up and wider width. Also just hits bone in foot.

Very uncomfortable shoes.

I was very surprised at how cheap these look for CK heels, the low quality is apparent as soon as you take them out of the box. I needed a simple pair of pumps for work and unfortunately these are also too tight.

Very tough material. Not flexible. I wouldn't recomend anyone to buy, looks like not leather at all.

Material was so stiff and not comfortable. Returning. Wouldn't recommend to buy anyone

These are WILDLY uncomfortable! The length was fine but they were too narrow. Also, they put a lot of pressure on the ball of my foot adding to the discomfort. Even sitting they hurt. Truly awful to wear. That being said I do think they are well made and super cute. They just aren’t the ones for me.