Customer Reviews Calvin Klein Gayle

Overall, these shoes are comfortable and attractive. I have a narrow foot, and narrows are hard to find. While this shoe only comes in a regular width, buying 1/2 size below my normal size made for a good fit. The heel height is flattering yet not too high and is easy to walk in. The only drawback is that the color is not a true red but more of an orangey red.

too large - had to send back

Cute shoes - love the heel bling! Wish the heel height was slightly taller but I’m returning them because they run big.

Too big and too tight across the toe box - otherwise would returned for half size smaller. Sad to have to send them back as they are GORGEOUS.

Size is half size larger.

These run small and are a little shinier than I expected. Got something I prefer from Sam Edelman.

I absolutely LOVE the Calvin Klein Gayle Pumps! I have five pairs. I prefer the ones with the gold band on the upper heel, but also have a couple pairs with the silver band.

I’m very disappointed with these shoes! Normally I am an 8.5, so I ordered up like reviews suggested but the 9 was still too small. I really wanted these shoes, so I tried a 9.5 (I’m never a 9.5). As suspected, that size was too big. If there was a 9.25...maybe these would in my closet! A real shame - the camel color is beautiful!

The shoes are very nice. The is color is perfect but it runs small. I recommend a size up

I wanted to love these shoes. I have flat feet was looking for a comfortable 3 inch pair of navy heels and I was hoping these were it. My biggest issue with this shoe is that the leather just isn’t comfortable or soft. It’s very stiff leather. While I have no problem on the heel or the height of the heel, the leather makes it an uncomfortably shoe. It really is a beautiful shoe (and the color is great) and I get a lot of compliments but I’m still looking for that perfect navy heel.

This shoe fits true to size.

I was on the lookout for a nice black heel to wear to work so I purchased this item along with 4 other black heels. When I saw the Calvin Klein box I was so excited to try them on however the split second I put these on I took them off and put them in the return pile. There is not much to say about these in regards to versatility. They look nice and that's about it. They are pinchy, narrow, too high, and have zero arch support - If I was planning on sitting all day, perhaps these would be a good fit but that's not reality and there's no way I would want to walk anywhere in these. I ended up keeping a different brand, the Naturalizer - Natalie style that were much more comfortable and looked very similar to these.

material is nice, but as a lady with wide feet these definitely cut into the tops of my feet despite me ordering the wide size.

This shoe definitely ran small. I am used to a pointed shoe...in fact, I love them, but these did not work. I am a pretty regular 10 and don't fluctuate from that size, so I would say to size up.

Really liked the heel height and gold accent. Too pinching to wear for any amount of time.

I love these shoes and am determined to make the work. They are tight in the toe area. I am wearing them around the house to break them in. I tried these shoes on in a store and the were perfect. It must be because they were tried on many times. I'll let you know if this works.

Listen to the reviewers who tell you that these run small. They do. I always where 8.5 M and I have to stuff my foot into this shoe box like I'm Cinderella's stepsister or something. I bought my size and one size up. Kept the one size up, sent back my normal size. I recommend going 1/2 size larger than you normally wear. Otherwise, this is a really attractive shoe; a small amount of toe cleavage once you find the size that fits. Heel is a very wearable but stylish height. The little metal bar on the back of it actually adds to the look of the shoe, rather than making it look tacky.

I loved this shoes. Perfect for what I needed. But...they run super narrow. I am normally an 8M. These were too narrow in that size. I then tried 8.5M, and still too narrow! I then tried to order them in Wide, but all sold out. No surprise! If you really want these shoes, I suggest waiting for Wide to come back in. Otherwise, find something else, which is what I did.

The shoe is beautiful but runs a bit small.

Beautiful shoe but was unhappy with how it feels and looks on the foot.

Very tight fitting.

I’ve purchased this shoe in other colors in the past and liked them. But these were extremely uncomfortable. They felt very tight on my toes and about a size too small. I have narrow feet and the outer sides of my toes were killing when I took them off. When you walk they also let out a puff of air, which when not wearing stockings creates an awful sound effect! Cute but not practical for work given these design flaws.

i have owned 3 other pairs of calvin klein heels that were all the same size. this one ran small.

Sending these back. They are incredibly narrow even though I bought the "W" width. Can barely get my normal sized foot into them! The color is OK but not exactly what I wanted.

Beautiful shoes but run really small to size.