Customer Reviews Minnetonka Cally Slipper

Seems VERY short. The sole is better than the last (looking for the traditional moccasin slipper type) but I generally wear a 7 1/2 and the 8 was a tight fit in the toes!

Really comfy slipper, actually had more support and cushion in the sole than expected, ran a little short though.

These Minnetonka's are not high quality. As soon as I tried to tie the leather it broke (old and stiff).

For some reason I ordered these in a 9 when in reality I'm a true 9.5... Needless to say they were too small but luckily fit my sister. That being said, I was a little disappointed that they weren't fluffier on the inside. So, while I could order a half size up I will instead look for a more comfy house/deck slipper.

Very cute and exactly the style that I was looking for, but my toes were a bit too squished in the 9 (I run 81/2-9). At the same time, they seemed big in the heel. Disappointing.

I have worn Minnetonka slippers for years now and have always needed to go down a size so I ordered an 8 and I wear an 8 1/2 . This was the first time their moccasins were too short for me. They do stretch but in width only. The size 9 s were to big and I slipped out of them. Maybe I just got the odd size 8's on this shipment.

This is my one year report...when I first got this shoe it was very snug but they did stretch out, they felt amazing and definitely kept my feet warm. A year later they have gotten severely worn out, now granted I wear them outdoors, but my right shoe is starting to get a hole where my big toe rubs, and the "fur" got raggedy after 6 months. My mom actually just got the Ugg version, and they seem to be sturdier but we will see. I would recommend these shoes for strictly indoors though.

I have loved Minnetonka's for years but it's very hard to get the right size if you are truly in the 1/2 size range. I wear a 7 1/2 and the 8 was way too large and the 7 really was too tight. Sadly, both had to go back. The slippers are super cushy inside and moccasins with soft soles never give support so this isn't the slipper for you if that is important.

I really liked the look and feel of these slippers. I usually wear a size 6 or 6.5, so I ordered a 6 base on other peoples' reviews. They are super cute, but sadly I have to return them. My big toe was touching the end of the slipper, but it was so wide (even after I tightened the leather ties) that it still would come off my heel as I walked. Wish they made these in a slimmer width! They would be perfect!

I was disappointed with these slippers. I ordered a size larger as others suggested. The length fit well but they were definitely too wide. The soles appear a little flimsy and do not look like they would last.

Bought these for my daughter as I have these and love them. She is usually a size 7 so I bought her a 7. Since her feet are a little narrow, she couldn't keep them on even after tightening the leather cord. We then bought a size 6 to try. This didn't work either, too short in length. My feet are wide so they work for me, but appear to be a problem if you have narrower feet.

Well these were not at all what I expected. I mistakenly thought they had real shearling not a faux fur. I didn't like that. The ties never stay where you want them, and re-tieing is useless! I wore them around the house and in only a few days they looked awful-the inside faux fur mats down pretty quickly and makes them roomier. I took the ties out, but they are needed for the slipper to hold its shape-replaced with shoestring. The biggest problem for me was the cheap glued on sole!! It wasnt quite glued on the right place causing my foot to slide off the sole when I walked!I thought they were a great deal at the time now I feel they were over-priced! Avoid this style in any brand if you dont want to replace the ties-I have read reviews for all different brands of this style and the ties never stay! I could have 'made them work' with the shoelaces but the sole made it impossible for me to wear them. I gave them to a family member with smaller feet(and always cold) and they wear them with several pairs of thick socks-the sole isnt as much of an issue but then they have feet 2 sizes smaller than mine!

I got these as a gift, they're cute and I think they would be good if they fit. I usually wear an 11 , they fit on my foot but my toes were smashed into them. I really wanted them to work out, but I'm afraid they have to go back. I was also a little disappointed with how thin the bottom was. I think it would be worth the money to buy the next step up with the stronger base if you intend to wear these out of the house.

Definitely wide as many have described and runs short. I wear an 8.5 and ordered a 9 as recommended. My toe comes right to the end, but don't want to size up or it'll fall off due to the gapping at sides. Tightened laces which help. Hopefully they'll stretch a bit at the toe.

I really liked the look of this slipper hoping to replace some moccasins that I had previously that were super comfortable. I got these in a size 9 for my normally 8 1/2 feet. They fit fine but the heel was so wide it would slip off when I walked which was not comfortable at all. I tried to tighten the lace but it still slipped when I walked so had to send these back. I ended up with a similar shoe by Sorel except without a heel and I like them just fine.

These are super comfortable shoes! But wearing them outside much probably isn't a good idea. The soles of the shoes aren't really made to be outside much. The aspects of weather and wear are very hard on the shoes.

These slippers are super comfortable, but the sole felt too small for the slipper. I felt tippy! Maybe if you wear them in that changes, but I didn't want to find out.

Comfortable, but sole is flat, thin and narrow which wears the leather down. I needed to order a half size down because my heel was slipping out. Not good for long outdoor wear.

These were way too big in a size 8, even though we buy this same style every year and my daughter has always worn size 8.

These are so warm and comfy. Wish there was a way to make the heel tighter. The heel slips up and down without socks. I've tried pulling the laces but that doesn't help.

Couldn't believe slipper wouldn't fit, but the toe room was very short. Good looking slipper, though.

Runs large! I wear a size 7 normally and bought the size 7. I have to wear thick socks to keep them from slipping. I would not wear these outside the house.

These look great, but the back kept slipping off. Also, if you like to wear socks with slippers, they bunch up in these.

Very comfortable with a ton of grip. The only bummer is the laces. They don't like to stay tied, and when I do try to tie them they snap leaving me with an unlaceable mess.

Good comfort shoe but the sole needs more cushion. It can hurt if you walk in it for a long time.