Customer Reviews Minnetonka Cally Slipper

These are very comfortable, but I wear a size 6.5 and ordered a 6 and after about 2 weeks, my slippers are totally stretched out. I have to wear socks with them to keep them from sliding off my heel. Definitely order the smaller size if you are a half size person. also, once the ties are untied, it's really difficult to keep them knotted after that.

I tried the 10 (normally my size on any shoe), and it was too small. Crammed my front toes. The 11 was too big. Too bad, because they are really cute!

These are really comfortable and great. My only thing is that they aren't meant to be worn so often, just for quick errands (like you would with slippers), the bow kept getting untied and that was really annoying. Overall if your bf or husband is buying it for you go ahead but I wouldn't spend $36 on shoes that will last 3-4 months.

Really cute slipper but it was way too big. Normally I wear a 5.5/6, so I got a 5 since the reviews said they run big. Even if I wore these with thick socks I don't think they would fit. I'm bummed because they are really nice.

I ordered the slipper for my 94 year old mother. A size 7 was too small and a size 8 was too large. I thought to keep them for myself, but the slipper offers no arch support. Might be great for someone else.

Cute slippers. I wish they felt more comfortable. Reading the reviews I ordered an 8. It was too small. I then ordered a 9. It would have been fine, but the toe area does not allow much vertical room. My toes felt too much pressure from the top of the slipper.

Average slipper, I don't think this brand is consistent. Ordered my size expecting it to be a little big due to other reviews and it was too small. :( I had to go a full size larger and the length fits now, but the top of the heel feels like it leans in at a forward angle - like it should've been made into a smaller shoe. It’s kind of uncomfortable but it’s not like I'm running around in them. Also, the Minnetonka tag under the heel isn't removable and it feels like there is something in your shoe. There is no cushion in the bottom (my husband has a pair that are so comfy).

Good shoes. But be careful; they are really tight when you buy them but they do stretch out quite a bit after 4 wears. The quality of these shoes is really good though.

This shoe is great to slip into without assistance, and stays on well. Purchased for Parkinson patient who has limited mobility and cannot reach own feet. Downside: bow won't stay tied, we superglued it.

Loved this slipper and the woolly liner is great quality. It's all around a perfect slipper. Unfortunately, they run tiny. I would recommend ordering a size bigger. I ordered an 11 (too small). They felt like a size 9 1/2 or 10. Wish they made a 12! I was so bummed out that I have to return them! Just waiting for my return labels. I really love the free shipping both ways!

Yes it is a slipper. You can wear it around school/office but do not walk the streets. The sole will wear down quickly.

As soon as I took it out of the box, I knew the size ran small, ordered an 8 wear a 7 1/2 returning for a 9. Very narrow, too.

I got this slipper to transition from cast to shoes after breaking my foot. Felt great at first, but the high back slants inward and rubs the back of my ankle. Also, flat as can be, so not comfortable to walk in. But great to run out and grab the paper in the morning. I prefer my Ugg slippers for around the house.

I really love these slippers, but the sizing is awful. They run very small and the larger sizes don't have 1/2 size. I need a 10 1/2 but had to get an 11 and stuff paper in the toe.

The shoe overall was comfortable but the back of the shoe felt too hard and hurt when walking in them. Also, the shoe was too wide and felt a little too small on my foot.

These slippers "fit" my foot in all the wrong ways (my foot's just slightly wider than average). I usually wear a 7.5, so I ordered a 7. It felt cramped in the toe and across the ball of my foot, while my heel slipped out with every step, which leads me to think that even if I ordered an 8, my heel would still slip out. That said, they seem to be well-made.

I bought these to wear around the house and they have served this purpose well. They are very warm. I bought a half-size smaller than I usually wear, and while they were tight at first, they have stretched out and they are fine now. In terms of comfort, I've noticed that they do push me to stand on the side of my foot, which probably isn't very good in the long run.

Seemed like good quality, comfy, cozy slippers but I just couldn't get the right sizing; my normal size was too small (too short toe to heel), and the next size up was super wide and wouldn't stay on my feet. I've got pretty normal sized feet and don't usually have a problem with fit, but I just couldn't make these work; but honestly, I found I had the exact same problem with the Uggs, so I guess this style of slipper-shoe just wasn't meant for me!

Like others have said, these run a half a size too small. Too bad because I really love the look, but not the fit.

I ordered a 10 because there was no 9 and 1/2 and they're too big. I would have had to stretch a 9.

I have been buying these slipper from Zappos for years and something in the materials has drastically changed. The lining seems to be made of a lower quality synthetic material that now has a sheen, loses plushness and all cushioning in less than a week. Really disappointing.

The quality of the moccasins is not what it used to be. Seem poorly made.

Love the style and was super soft but slipped off my foot while walking. The toe was tight but the rest super loose so unable to size down sadly. Really wanted to like this one.

I normally order slippers from another brand but thought I would try these Minnetonkas for a change. The comfort level was inferior, so I put in another lining: not the best solution, though it helped. Now, the toes have holes in them, even though the slipper fits loosely on my foot. Meanwhile my other brand is going strong after years of wear.

These mocs don't look like they used to. Just not as nice and precise as in the old days. My right foot is larger than my left but in this pair the right slipper gaps and comes off my foot at every step. Fall hazard! The left seems to fit OK, while I might have expected this to be looser. If Zappo's can send me a pair that fits, I will exchange them. If not, I'll have to return.