Customer Reviews Minnetonka Cally Slipper

I've worn this slipper for many years - This year when I ordered my usual size, I felt that my medium width felt (and looked) like narrow, and the size was a little shorter than usual, so I had to order the next size up. I was also unhappy bec they changed the lining, which use to come plush. This lying is "silky" and lies immediately flat, greatly reducing the comfort level. It however is the best moccasin for the price.

Size is really odd. 7 is too small and 8 is way big. My older pair is an 8 and fits perfect.

Size 8 is my normal size but they were 1/2 size to big. 7 would have been to small. To bad because I really liked them.

I am almost always a size 8. Every once in awhile a 7.5 will do. These shoes were falling off my feet when I tried to walk. I would need a 7 in this style! Which is weird because I’m a size 8 in other minnetonka slippers.. So either the sizing was a fluke of an experience or you should DEFINITELY order a full size down.

Bought 8Med. in Red Suede and they are very pretty. However, seem a little short and a 9 would be too long. The width at the back and heels of the shoes seems a little wide but, tried pulling on the outside leather strings to tighten and helped some. Will try them and if they stay on will keep. The sole bottoms seem a little rough.Will try.

These felt too wide and my heel would flip out but, I wouldn’t be able to size down. I wore a pair of slippers out that are no longer available so I thought these would do the trick. Unfortunately, had to send back bc they wouldn’t stay on my feet and I wear these at home when cleaning and organizing so they have to be able to stay put

The slipper seems oddly proportioned. Its seems wide but if i were to go down a size, it would most likely be too short then. I tightened the strings to help snug it up a little and that helped. Not sure if that's what they are intended for? Otherwise they are good for around the house now.

I ordered my normal size shoe and it was comfy adn perfect fit. Only issue I did not like was teh fur did not seems to comfort the back heel as much especially at the top edge. I felt like it would give me a rubbed heel, yes slippers giving pain. So i returned. Going to go back to my old style slippers, slide in!

These are super comfy. Definitely run big. I wear 7.5 or 8 in women’s sneakers and 7 was the right size and actually got roomier as the ‘fur’ flattened out. I really enjoy these slippers but I wanted them instead of wearing socks around the house however after a month and a half, they smell. TMI, but the synthetic material doesn’t lend well to wearing without socks.

So I’m a 7-1/2 but read reviews and ordered a 7... it fit like it was an 8-1/2. Returned for a 6 and haven’t yet received it. I feel like after reading reviews and having owned these exact shoes in an 8 before, the shoes just aren’t ever measured correctly. You’re taking a shot in the dark with sizes. I have no idea what the 6 will be like. Like I said I have had an 8 in these before and they got fine. But the 7 way too big. Good luck

These are lovely slippers but very wide and no way to make them narrower.

The style is super cute but the size was a full size smaller than my regular size 7, I live with some foot pain and decided not to streach them out by wearing them.

I usually wear a 7 1/2 - 8 and ordered the 8 in these slippers. They are definitely at least a half size to full size larger as they flip off my heels. That said, they are extremely comfortable to wear and are super cute. I would recommend these slippers but just be mindful of the size difference.

These slippers are super cute but they do not cover as much of my foot as I want. I'm specifically purchasing warm furry slippers for the colder months and unfortunately these just did not offer that full-foot warmth that I'm looking for...I've been told I have longer than average toes so maybe that's what's wrong. Returning them to get something with more coverage. These slippers were cozy though and would work great as a general house slipper.

These run big. I would slip out of them if the laces were not tied as tight as possible. And unfortunately on that note, I broke a lace last night tying them up, and I’ve had them for only about a month now. That’s disappointing. But, aside from that, they are cozy to wear around the house. And warm. But hard to keep clean because they are suede and light pink.

The bad news: Felt half size too short. The cut of the loafer tongue on the right shoe was defective/crooked. No arch support at all. Thin soles. Not for wearing out of the house, but that's where I'll wear them anyway. The good news: The style is cute. They are warm and cozy (even tho' the fur lining is faux). They slip on and off easily. They are relatively inexpensive.

These slippers were enormous! I wear a size 5M but I have a slightly wide foot- not enough for wide shoes though. These felt like at least a 5.5 and they gapped on sides from the toe box to the very wide heel area! I walked right out of them. I'm sad because I loved the color and I thought they were cute. Lately, size 5 shoes have been running too large for me! This is making me panic because it is difficult as it is to find size 5 shoes

I wear a 8.5 or a 9 and the 9 was much too big. I ordered an 8 which is still too wide for my narrow foot and I can always add socks.

These are so cute and well made but felt at least a half size too large. I wear a size 9W as shoes seem to be getting narrower these days. The width was not wider in the toe box, but rather the heel and the footbed was so long for a 9! I also tried the sorels in a 9 and they were also super long but skinny in toe box. Too bad, as both are super nice aside from the odd fit.

I'm returning these slippers because they are so wide they are sloppy...They flop off my feet! Disappointing, as they look nice.

I was disappointed with these. They seemed cheaply made. My big toe was pressing against the top like it was going to break through the seams and yet somehow my heal would easily slide out and they were quite wide at the same time. Just a strange fit overall and the front part of the moccasins was too short. I feel like it should cover more of the top of your foot, mine barely covered my toes. And I don't have freakishly long toes or anything. The only redeeming quality was how very soft they felt inside.

So I think that the trick with these slippers is that you have to wear socks with them. With the combination of the tag on the boys bottom heel and the rubbing on the ankle they fit with socks true to size. These were only a few of the choices that came in a half size so I decided to keep them. Overall just okay.

Wish these slippers did not lose their shape and vividness after just a few wearings. Worst of all, the tie just doesn't stay tied. Why can't Minnetonka fix this known flaw? I only purchased again because of a zappos reward which brought the cost to $5.

These are incredibly cute, but do seem to run about 1/2 size too big. It makes sizing difficult because they only come in whole sizes.

This slipper feels very nice with nice material but has a super strange fit. I have a size 7.5/8 foot and when I put the size 7 slipper on it flopped right off my foot, which I was not expecting. It definitely fits wide, which doesn't work for me because I have a narrow heel. And the toe box is very short so that doesn't help it stay on. I know slippers aren't supposed to have an exact fit, but these wouldn't work for me at all.