Customer Reviews Cole Haan Stassi Penny Loafers

Size 6 is my size, but this style is for wide feet. Beautiful leather. Please make 5 1/2 in these.

Very comfortable, and well-made. I ordered the wide width, and couldn't be happier. The shoe fits just a little wide on me, but as soon as I put on socks, it's perfect. I can walk miles in these shoes, which is what I was looking for from a loafer. No more tightness around the toes. The footbed is also very comfortable, and there's no need for me to purchase inserts. I love how sleek it looks, while also having a decent sole. Not bulky, certainly timeless style. I highly recommend!

sadly, Too big, had to return

very comfortable; beautiful shoe. would buy again!

Love these shoes. So comfortable and great flats.

Perfect from the start. No blisters…no need to break them in. Great quality!

Love these so much. fits true and really comfortable.

good

Stunning and so comfy. I got the burgundy and white version. It’s classy and so current. Get it!

slipped at heal. did order 5.5 size and keeping Thank you

I love these - so comfortable! I compared them to the Madewell Corrine,l loafer, which I also own and love, and these feel a little softer. I did find they run a bit large. I am almost always a 9 but swapped them for an 8.5.

Very pretty shoe, but did not feel quite right

Just too big

Overall this is a great show. My problem is with a little loop on the belt of it and with how high up the foot the front comes up. If not for those two minor details, I would absolutely keep the shoes. They just looked a little bit "old fashioned".

Beautiful shoe, afraid to try the wide, reviews say wide in the heel :-(

It is a little bit longer. Beat thing is it is easy to exchange, Zappos' best customer service.

I wear a 6 and this was a bit too big and my heel kept sliding out.

Comfortable and cute shoe. The patter in very pronounced but if that's the look you're going for, it is a fun shoe. They're a very classic silhouette.

Too wide for my foot. I can wear some brands in Medium, but not these.

The width was very comfortable but I feel that the shoe runs larger than normal. I generally wear a 7 and even with thick socks the shoes were too big. The heel area as well seemed to run wider than most.

Beautiful shoe, heel to large, my length and width good, heel to wide.

Initially tried on in usual size 8.5 but felt tight/short. Wasn't sure how/if shoe would stretch, so to avoid a too-tight fit, I ordered a 9 to compare and it felt better out of the box. I have room to wear a thin sock if it gets bigger as I wear them. Will definitely want to Scotchguard the suede for a wet midwestern winter.

The design makes the toe look really long and thus a bit awkward - especially for a larger - size 10 - foot. Otherwise it is a comfortable fit as Cole Haan usually is.

I know I am a D width, and these are a C. I thought I would try, but they were in fact to narrow for my foot.

I ordered a 7.5 W and could not get my foot in there w/o damaging the shoe. The shoe and box said Wide, but it felt like a regular. I always felt that Cole Haan shoes were narrow, even when I didn't wear a wide. This just proved it. Too bad, it was a nice looking shoe.