Customer Reviews Cole Haan Stassi Penny Loafers

I wish Cole Haan could get the HEEL fit right on the wide shoes. The 9W fit perfectly BUT FOR the heel which would slip and rub on every step. Wide in the toe box doesn't need wide in the heel. I wish I could have kept them!

These loafers came up #2 (out of 9!) in my recent "Great Black Loafer Search!" If I needed two pairs of black loafers I'd have gone with them in a heartbeat. My winner, Pikolinos "Aldaya" has removable insoles, so my left-foot orthotic fits, this Cole Haas doesn't have them. If both your feet are the same size, get the Stassi! Great quality and more comfortable than the Bass Weejuns I loved but which were horrible to break in.

Good quality, classic style. This shoe enclosed the foot more (the sides are higher) than the Sarto loafers I originally tried and I found these to be more comfortable.

The fit and look are great. My only issue is the stitching on the top, inside of the shoe is ruff and over time cut into my skin. If you plan to wear these without socks, you may want to choose another style.

Cute style, but a bit narrower than expected.

Was a bit snug at first but they stayed on my feet all day and by the end of the day they felt great.

I can either be an 8 or 8.5 M, but since loafers need to fit snugly I went with the 8. They're a little too tight with the light/midweight socks I planned to wear with them, but the real problem for me was the lining. The outer part of the shoe is leather, but the lining is a manmade material that made my feet hot after just a few minutes. They're cute shoes, but not worth sweaty feet! These are going back.

Very comforfable perfect loafer. I almost always wear an 8.5 in close toed shoes but the 8 fit perfectly. I have medium width feet (maybe slightly slim) and they fit perfectly. I bought the brown which is a beautiful shade and ended up getting the black too

It fit quite well and comfortable.

My favorite loafers. Wearing all the time

The only problem with these shoes is the soles are slippery. As much as I love the pattern, I can't have slippery soles for the amount of walking I do.

The fit was small, but because the shoe is suede, it will probably stretch over time. This is a nice, flat loafer, but a bit too classic and generic for my taste.

Usually wear a 6.5 wide sandals and 7 wide in boots so I got these in 6.5 wide and though they fit, it was tight enough in the back that it was hard to take on and off without trying to manually break in the leather. I got a 7 wide and they are easier to take on and off and still grip my foot.

Well made loafer that fit like a glove. I typically take an 8 1/2 or 9 and the 9 fit very well. I would recommend your usual size unless you're in between sizes, then size up . I haven't worn them yet but they're pretty soft so I don't expect a break in period.

Well made shoe. I see others' reviews that the shoe is stiff. I wouldn't disagree. However, it is sturdy. It is not a soft, malleable leather like you might find in a moccasin. If you are looking for a high quality shoe that offers structure and stability, this is it. Very professional look for work. After a few wears it loosened a little. I ordered 9W and it is true to size.

Beautiful Chocolate Suede Loafers! Perfect for fall. They look great with black slacks for work or jeans on the weekend. Also, very comfortable and stylish. I just ordered another pair in black leather to rotate them out for the fall season.

Really cute. Definitely a darker shade than advertised but not a huge deal. Toe box could be wider but will prob stretch a bit. Good solid loafer that i know CH is known for.

stylish and comfy

Really cute shoes but maybe half size too big. Will exchange for smaller size.

Perfect!

A little bit longer. Easy exchange, best customer service

I really like this loafer. The footbed and sole allow your foot to move naturally with almost no heel slippage. They don't rub the back of my heel. AND they don't gape at the sides when you walk. They literally checked every box I was looking for in this classic look.

great quality shoes with really clean style