Customer Reviews Cole Haan American Classics Penny Loafers

I'm size 9 I bought size 9 and when I walk they come off my feet

The shoe is a bit wider than the fitting chart indicates but is otherwise as advertised.

There are nice but I little big

Not quite what I expected from the photographs. Too shiny and felt like plastic. Kept them, but likely won't wear much. Wish Cole Haan would bring back the Nantucket loafers.

I loved the quality and appearance of the product but a full half size too large!

Shoes fit tight so if you have wide feet definitely go with a wide selection

Nice style but the quality is low. The leather feels plastic/rubbery and the soles also are made of cheap materials. This shoe is also made in India. I could have excused all of this if the shoes at least fit properly- but they run 1/2 size large.

It's a beautiful shoe but too big. I normally wear a size 12 medium and ordered these at size 12 but they're huge, like a size 13!

Really the comfort of the shoes and the design 10/10, however the Size runs too big, I am 10.5 W and I ordered them 10 W and however I want they stay big, I must wear 3 socks to fit correctly.

Very dark shoe. The wine color doesn't really come out until the shoe starts to wear and crease. Comfortable shoe though and stylish.

Nice shoe but not made in my size

Sized a full size down and they fit perfect

Runs wide and big, I couldn't use it when I buy it

I ordered a wide but the shoe remains tight on my foot. I am an 81/2 wide. The 9 wide unfortunately were very tight.

Great shoes but too big !!!!

Very large fit. Try a size a half smaller. I wear a 13 wide and this shoe in 13 regular was a bit larger than most shoes I have bought.

I must say I'm rarely disappointed when it comes Cole Haan shoes but these run big and the sole looks and feels really cheap. I must say on a positive note the shoe is very comfortable and minus the sole it's a good looking shoe.

Shoes are nice quality, but my heel kept slipping out. I have 6 other pairs of CH in the exact same size and they fit great.

Shoe quality is not what I expected from my other Cole Haan purchases. Leather feels a bit cheaper than what I am accustomed to and the interior of the shoe doesn't feel like it breathes well. Sole is also large and bulky compared to traditional penny loafers.

I returned the shoes because of the poor materiel quality and stitching. I purchased Dr Martin instead, much better quality material and heavy stitching.

I am size 12M, had bought at least 10 other Cole Haan shoe pairs the same size without a problem. However, for some reason, these shoes (which I wanted really bad) were too long even after placing additional soles. The back of the shoes were rubbing against my achilles heel even with the additional soles. Ended up returning.

Poor quality shoes. I expected more from your brand.

Not comfortable if you have a wide foot,even wide model. Sent them back.

Bert 'splashy' and big, especially in the heel.

Great look but the size was a bit large and they stretch more than normal. I have been wearing ColeHaan for 30 years. Somewhat disappointing.