Customer Reviews Cole Haan American Classics Penny Loafers

Very comfortable! My favorite shoe period.

True sizing, well - constructed

Comfortable fashionable stylish

They run large and I wish I had gotten 2 pair. Amazingly comfortable!

Love these shoes! The style and comfort are great

A timeless classic loafer for business and casual attire.

Classic Look and feel! Perfect fit

Nice shoe, had to return, was a bit large, when trying to get best size, it was taken :~(

These shoes are great but I do have a concern about ordering by shoe size. I have ordered two pairs of Cole Hann shoes, both size 11, within the previous few months. But they don't fit me the same. One pair of shoes is a bit too tight and the latest pair is a bit too loose.

Good quality , but the size runs big on this one. I usually wear 11 and the shoe looks and feels like a 11

Attractive and comfortable. This shoe style seems to run 1/2 to a full size larger. I have many pairs of Cole Haans and ordered 4 different pairs recently. This style was too large.

Great shoe. Ordered wide and 1/2 number smaller to a good fit. It took two orders to get the tight size. But worth it.

Looks handsome, looks well made, very light. Out of the box, the shoe collar rubbing on my ankle bone. However, I know it will break in good as me trying to massage the collar seems to help.

Nice design with best material.

Could be lighter in color

Great patent leather look burgundy chunky loafer with snug but comfortable fit. This is an versatile shoe that you can dress up or down with a more modern look than your classic loafer. The sole is definitely a larger foamy rubber than I expected but you quickly appreciate its comfort and the beautiful design make up for the larger chunkier sole. My foot quickly molded to the rubber and leather and they quickly have become my go-to comfort shoe with pizazz.

Nice loafer with firm but forgiving fit.

When I opened my box of loafers, I was disappointed. My shoes just came in a naked box. Normally they would have been protected with tissue and plastic bags. Once I put them on, very comfortable and stylish. Wore them chino pants and Oxford shirt, which I received many compliments.

Nice shoe, well made. I'm not in love with the fatter soles with foam layer. They trip me up while walkingtake them off and drop them on the tile floor and they actually bounce! Fit well, comfortable but for the oddness of the thick foam.

They are very classy looking

Comfortable. They look a bit clunkier than I expected

This is a well made and beautiful shoe. I'd give it 5 stars except it did not fit me. I often wear a 41 or 42 and this 42 was a little too long and my heel slipped. Cole Hahn has a great return policy so I'll get a refund and next time try on the shoe in person rather than order over the mail.

Good shoe , not their best