Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe

This is my 5th pair of J&M shoes and so far they are my favorite; dressy casual style are my go-to shoes.

My husband loves the shoes. He said they are very nice and comfortable to wear. I will be purchasing another pair.

J&M offers great fit, comfort, and style, but I have to warn prospective customers about a complete lack of durability with the Uptons. I wore the shoe in black and oiled tan lightly around my office, with very little walking, and within a year the soles start peeling off the bottoms of both pairs. I have had other J&M shoes around the same price where this did not happen. The real problem is how this has even come to interfere with driving, as the peeling soles catch on my floor mats while operating brake and gas pedals. Would love to see J&M address this defect.

Super comfortable with the style I was hoping for.

I struggle to find shoes that accomodate my high instep and wider foot. These fit very well, quite comfortable, and even my teen daughters think they look good!

Good toe box and fits well. Good look shoe for business casual.

Great shoe. First day at work I creased it and damaged the foam so he mindful of the type of work you wear these too

Great fit and look. Very lightweight and comfortable.

First pair of JM will be buying more in the future

Usually a 10.5 w with J&M shoes u til this shoe. Needed an 11 w.

I have never had a proper pair of leather tie up shoes. My grandfather only wears Johnston and Murphy and swears by their amazing line of footwear. He bought me a pair for my college graduation and I must admit, I am now a diehard advocate of J&M

Very comfortable and quality is very good

Very very comfortable!

Super comfortable shoes that are great for work casual wear. The leather is soft enough for some aging marks that add to a less formal look. Perfect shoe with khakis.

These shoes look terrific with a breezy linen suit and are very comfortable!

Comfortable and look good. I finally found a pair that fit.

J&M remains one of very few quality manufacturers of quality shoes, etc. Their custom shop Ive used before are my pride in dress shoes. One i ok f few supplying wide (E & EE) sizes. Ive tried multiple others (Allen Edmunds, etc) and quality of J&M exceeds theirs in finish, stitching, soles and very importantly the lining for durability & comfort.

Id say a lot of things about the quality and comfort of the shoes I bought. The design is very fancy and my husband loved it. But Id like also to comment about the amazing costume service this company has. I hope it keeps like this forever.

I ordered a 12 wide. I got it. The shoe was at least a 14. Dont know what happened. Totally turned off.

Very comfortable. Would buy another pair.

"Wide" is not wide enough. The pointed toe squeezes toes together. Need to make "WWWW" or make a boxier toe. I did appreciate the no hassle return policy.

Shipping Costs adds to much on some items

Very comfortable, truly a good fit , purchase

The shoe is very comfortable and looks great with jeans.

They look and feel great.