Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe

Nice looking shoe but materials felt cheap and the leather was low quality.

Pretty good they did give me blisters the first wear tho

These shoes are very comfortable and stylish.

The most comfortable commuting shoe on the market. Stylish, yet refined to match with any outfit

The color is perfect and they are so comfortable

I have never been disappointed with my J&M purchases: highest quality and good fit.

I am incredibly impressed with the fit, finish, and craftsmanship of the Upton Plain Toe shoe! Having a wide foot makes it difficult to find a stylish shoe that fits as advertised. This shoe fits and looks exactly as advertised. My foot fits comfortably without any of those annoying pressure points around the pinky toe. The attention to detail in the finish is evidentthe stitching is precise, and the materials feel luxurious. From the flexible sole to the soft interior foam, every aspect exudes quality. Whether Im walking or standing, I appreciate the support and durability this shoe provides. Plus, multiple colleagues at work have commented on my shoes and asked where I purchased them. This shoe has made me a believer and I will definitely be purchasing again.

Very comfortable and stylish

I purchase this shoe in the past and ordered a pair in the wide size for more room in the toe box. The wide size was better for the toe box but the rest of the shoe was too large. Sending back to order the medium width.

Very comfortable office shoes. After trying different dress shoes I got these and they are super comfortable and goes well with office wear. I would recommend this shoe to anyone looking for comfortable dressy shoe.

Great shoe. I did have to size up a half size as this style might be a bit more narrow than others.

These shoes are very light and super comfy. High quality as expected. Seem to be very well made. Perfect to wear with just about anything. Looking forward to having these for a long time.

I purchased these shoes previously and they fit perfect out of the box. One of the more comfortable shoes I own. So much so I purchased a second pair in a different color, which also fit perfect out of the box (10.5 Medium). However, I did have an issue with the sole on one pair and J&M sent a replacement. When I tried on the replacement, they fit much more narrow in the toe box than the first 2 pairs I owned. I called J&M and they sent another replacement, which also fit narrow in the toe box. Something must have changed with their manufacturing process or facility. Nonetheless, I like the shoes enough that I am going to try a 10.5 wide to see if that fits more like the original pair. J&M customer service was great so no complaints there. Hopefully the wides resolve the issue .

Comfortable fit. Slight color difference between shoes

A little stiff when new, but just took about a week. Overall a great shoe, in a classic look and color great for business casual dress. I think this sole construction will hold up well compared to other styles.

This is my second pair of the Upton Plain toe, which is a very stylish and comfortable shoe that I absolutely, love! However, this last pair I ordered and just received, the Tan Oiled full grain, looks nothing like the picture on the website - it has more of a "gold" color hue to it, than what I would consider "tan". I thought about sending them back but decided to just keep them. Definitely plan to order another pair in a different color for the fall.

Very comfortable shoe, light weight, looks great!

Bought for husband; he loves them. Light weight and comfortable. A very good buy.

Very pleased with the fit and comfort coupled with the style of the shoe.

When do you expect to have wide sizes in these shoes. I have a pair in a different color that came in wide and they are great.

Everything was fine, especially my new shoes which are fabulous!!

Love these shoes

Good style with comfort to go along with

This shoe is trendy and comfortable! I get compliments all the time when I wear them. I actually have multiple pairs of this style shoe in different colors. Great look for work or for a casual night out.

I waited 2 weeks for the shoes to ship and I received the wrong size. I returned them at a local store only to be told that my size hasnt been available for a while