Customer Reviews L.L.Bean Wicked Good Slippers Squam Lake

I really wish I would've gone with wicked good slippers, as these have no ankle support

They do not hold the foot firmly so ankles slip inward and very uncomfortable. I would have returned them but they were a gift.

I've been wearing this style for years now. Over the years I've noticed the lining of the slippers got thinner and cheaper! They don't last as long as they used to. Due to the thinner lining and cheaper material my feet are always cold! It saddens me to say I won't be ordering any slippers from LL Bean again!

Usually, I love these slippers and buy myself a new pair wvery year. I was happy to see the pink ones on sale; however, I didn't expect that they would be worn. The leather had indents where it bends with walking, the sides were scuffed and the soles were dirty. Very disappointed (I'm not sure of the sizing because I didn't put my feet in them. But it was mandatory I answer, so based that on previous purchases)

They wore on the inside. Had 3 weeks and returned.

I have ben buying Wicked Good Slippers for years and always ordered the same size. When my most recent order arrived, the slippers were way too large. They kept falling off even when I wore socks. I returned them and ordered the next size down. When the replacement order arrived, I could barely squeeze my foot inside. They were much shorter and more narrow than the original order. There seems to be a quality control issue going on. There should not be that much difference between sizes. I donated the slippers and will never order them again.

I just received these slippers today and after walking in them for less than a minute, I was so DISAPPOINTED! The arch support is in a very weird place...almost near the middle of my heal and definitely not where your arch support is required. Prior to ordering these slippers, I had recently visited a local shoe retailer where they actually measured my feet, and determined that I was an 8.5, so I ordered an 8 in these slippers based on the reviews recommending to order down. These slippers slide off the back of my feet because they're obviously too big, but I'm certain a size 7 (which is my only option since they don't come in half sizes), would be too small! I'll be returning. Only positive is that the shearling lining is warm and one of the features I was looking for. Overall, not worth the money when the fit is a huge disappointment.

I love LLBean! Love the quality of the products I purchase. Have been shopping this catalog for decades! So disappointed with this slipper. The wicked good "moccasin" is my go to slipper. Fantastic slipper!! So true to size. I am a size 7.5 and order an 8. Fits perfectly! So cozy and feels luxurious! I cannot say the same for the Squam. It is too wide and too long. Just a terrible fit. The shearling and slipper itself is quality but not the size. And because it is too wide sizing down will not matter. So I will return it.

The shoe was totally different from the first pair I bought. Fit was horrible. Not even a back, it was like a mule.

I've had a pair of these same slippers for years, worn with much comfort and cushion. Needed a new pair, so ordered new ones. Sadly the sole is now very, very hard. Absolutely no cushion. Disappointed.

I bought these slippers for myself at Christmas time and the were the sorriest shoes I have ever bought from llbeanI buy a new pair every year but since the quality isn't as good as they were at one time don't think I will anymore.

No arch support, wide and flops off foot, expensive

Sizing advice was wrong. Told me to go up a half size and I did. Slippers were too loose.

Ordered a size 8 online for my usual 7/7.5 feet, but the pair I received felt different on each foot. The left shoe was comfy and had enough room even with socks on, but the right shoe was extremely snug and the back barely fit over my heel. I thought I was going crazy, like are my feet really that different in size? But when I compared the left shoe with the right shoe, I could see there were structural differences. The left toe box was wider than the right, the left shoe overall was wider and longer than the right when I lined up the soles. Sad because the left fit great and was comfy, but the two shoes are so noticeably different that I will be returning.

I wear and ordered a women's size 5. These slippers were definitely NOT a size 5, they were more like a size 6 or larger :(

I am trying again with a different style of slipper

These slippers run small. I got my normal size 8.5 medium but they were too tight. I have then to my Mother who is a size smaller than me & she loved them until they started rubbing on her heel. She had to stop wearing them.

I wish I would have read the reviews first. These are terrible quality. I purchased online. For reference, I have narrow and flat feet, I'm 5'8" tall and 130lbs. I normally wear an 8.5 so sized up to the 9 as suggested by the website as they don't come in half-sizes. They are much too big; I should have sized down as suggested by the other reviewers. They are very wide too; they won't stay on my feet without wearing a pair of socks. I've had these slippers for exactly 14 days. I wear them only inside, when I get out of bed in the morning before getting dressed for the day and again after getting ready for bed, so for 2-3 hours a day. The sole of the shoe has no shape, support, firmness or cushioning. The fluff lining the sole was nice for first few days but has compressed completely. After wearing these my feet hurt as they offer no support or cushioning between me and the hard-wood floors. I will be returning; I'm disappointed with my first slipper purchase from LL Bean and I cannot recommend these.

I got these for Christmas 2023 and the picture is Christmas 2024. Used to love Wicked Good Slippers. They are not the quality they used to be.

I had great hopes for these slippers, but they were disappointing because my feet slid off the soles to the sides and I was afraid I'd sprain my ankle. The shearling bag is warm and comfortable, but I had to return them.

I got these in March and it's December. I get that sheepskin stretches but I bought a size 7 (I'm 7.5) and they are now way too big to wear. If I paid $40 for them I'd be more pragmatic but for $90 slippers, seems like they should last a year?

Unfortunately my slippers did not wear well and the right slipper wore down to the leather in 2 years. I only wear them a couple hours a day! The rubber sole is perfect and barely worn so it's disappointing.

I was surprised just how badly these slippers stretch out. IMO they are NOT true to size, I have had them a couple of months, they fit fine when I first tried them on, now they are a good inch and a half LONGER and are very sloppy on my feet now. I would order a size DOWN from your normal size. The last slippers I bought from LL Bean lasted 12 years, these won't make it through the Winter.