Customer Reviews KEEN Astoria West Sandal

Size up by at least a half size

Unfortunately, I have to return due to blister on my little toe. They were slight too cushy for me with insufficient arch support. Size and width were fine. My size is consistent with Merrell, Adidas, Nike, ASICS, and Brooks.

I like this one except it felt narrow.

bought two pair and they are very tight. I will keep them and wear them and see if they stretch out. I love everything about them except the tightness.

I feel like the sole of the ssandal was unconfortable, it make my feet feel hot, and burn

The arch support isn't in the right spot for me, but would be good for my high arch if it did. Plus, they are too tight for my high instep.

I thought these fit fine, though I had difficulty getting in/out of them as there is no Velcro strap. They felt okay at first, I went on a long walk first wearing and they gave me large blisters on both heels and on the ball of one foot. The footbed is soft, but the back of the footbed is NOT. The sandal must be slipped on, there are NO straps that open. The ankle strap really isn’t able to stretch very much, making it difficult to get on/off. These are going back, I guess they are too small even though they look huge.

Loved the look. But I need less of a heel. I need the Whisper flatter sole.

The arch support felt terrific out of the box, but it soon became clear they were too narrow top to bottom (as in top of foot to sole of the foot). And they were HOT, my feet sweating immediately! These seem to look cute on other people, but on me like clown feet. Returned.

too small

I bought different pairs of shoes like this, all different brands, for a trip to the Galapagos. Unfortunately, they are just not a good choice for a woman with thick ankles.

felt cheap on my foot

Very disappointed. I have several pairs of Keens and an 8 has been perfect fit each time. This shoe is almost a full size too small!! I can't believe that a brand like Keen has such bad size standards. I gave it 3 stars only because overall it is a nice-looking shoe and looks well made.

I really like the look of these (I bought the black ones), as well as the extra cushioning in the heel. However, the toe box does not work for my foot. I am not sure why, but it feels as if the toe box is too low or too small, and it puts pressure on my big toe when I take a step. I was recently diagnosed with big toe arthritis in one foot, so these shoes won't work for me. It's a shame since I like the look more than the Keen Whisper.

Show too tight across arch

The straps were uncomfortable. Too tight for my foot, even when I loosened the straps.

Inside the sandal is made different than the last pair I had. It felt like there was not enough room for my toes in the height, not the width.

Reason for return: I need at least 1 to 1.5 inch rise from ball of foot to heel. Was not aware heel bed depressed - not high enough for me

These are such a disappointment because the color way is absolutely gorgeous and modern. I tried them in both my usual 9 and then a 9.5 and both felt very small. The arch support hit too far forward and my heel was slipping off the back but also wasn’t. I definitely have a narrow foot so that wasn’t the problem, I’m fact I had plenty of room from top to Bottom and side to side. Sadly both pair will have to go back and I’ll have to consider a different style. I’m seriously sad about it because it is a gorgeous shoe.

Like many other reviews the shoe does run on the short side. I found that my heel hung over the end a tad when I had them on. While I was trying them out my heel kept on slipping. I've tried several Keen shoes and found they aren't a good fit for my feet. In future I'll bypass this brand.

Very cute, couldn't get them on. All my Keens ( 5 pair) are size 9 and fit perfectly. These are way off.

The Sandal was too narrow and the straps too hard. It hurt my little toes.

Too narrow. Must return.

Too narrow.