Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Hayes Tassel Loafers

My size is 10.5 but I got these size 10 since the others were too big and were slipping especially at the heel. These fit fine. I like the very soft sheepskin insole. These loafers are quite stylish especially with the tassels.

Fit and size are perfect. Have worn J&M Tassel loafers for over 20 years. Excellent quality and good looking shoes.

I ordered size 12 and size13 were sent…. Will return and try to reorder

Shoe is handsome! It is snug, but not too much so. Feels like after several wearings it will be personalized perfectly. Really like them so far!

Beautiful, but I must return. Too narrow for my wide foot.

I need the next smaller size. The width seems ok. Please let me know when you have 11.5W

My husband wears a size 9 in most shoes. When the Johnston & Murphy loafers arrived, he found the 9’s to be loose. We returned them (easily! with return label.). Reordered an 8 1/2. The second pair arrived quickly. The smaller size was a better fit. Very handsome shoe.

I purchased these for my husband. The right foot heels would slip as he walk. But after we inserted the sole cushion it fits perfectly. Depends on the style and the manufacture, he fits into the sizes 8.5 or 9. We are very pleased. I know this has nothing to do with this pair, but would you stop carrying the shoes that are made by Nike as they are made by the slave labor?

I wanted a pair of shoes styled somewhere between jean casual, and dressy brogues (my 20 year old J & Ms)I originally ordered my usual Johnson and Murphy size 10, but they were way to loose in the heel. I exchanged them for a size 9.5, and they fit fine. Maybe my feet are shrinking, or it’s just the loafer style, but these fit grea nowt! As usual, Zappos was easy to work with, and they replaced my shoes very quickly at no cost to me. Kudos!

Quality exceeded my expectations. Fit is perfect thanks to Wide width which is difficult to find.

Beautiful shoe - just too narrow for my fat foot

Excellent shoes. Tight fit at first but shape and mould quickly to your foot. Extremely comfortable. Very well-made and outstanding value for price. Johnson and Murphy is an experienced shoe manufacturer and it shows. I have 4 other styles of their shoes too, all just as good as these. I’ll be getting a second pair of these loafers in Brown. Highly recommended.

Beautiful shoe, but too small for me. I'm wearing orthotics now and couldn't make it work.

The fit was fine but a bit loose in the back... Not a real problem... Out of the box they are really slick on the bottom so watch your step! These shoes are great for any occasion...

The fit was great. Excellent arch support. Love the quality and my grandkids love the shine and tassel. Hard to beat a good J&M loafer.

Wonderful product and service. They didn't fit.

Love these shoes quality comfort combined with great looks. I suppose in making shoes for 170 years you learn a thing or two or 3....

I ordered a size 9M, the size and width fit was exactly what I needed. I wore them for about 3 hours when I received them and my feet were very comfortable. There were no tight areas in the toes or rubbing in the heel area. A very good shoe for the price.

Well constructed, high quality materials. Inner lining soft and comfortable. Value for money spent 5 stars.

Wore this shoe for years in a D width but now the D is too tight on me. The EE is comfortable but the 12EE shoe is a half size too long for me. Hoping they get an 11.5 EE in stock soon that I can try because I like the shoe a lot.