Customer Reviews Sofft Sharnell II Waterproof

Beautiful boots, but as other reviewers said, they run quite narrow. Had to return but wish they hade wides.

Beautiful boot, but ran narrow.

I wanted to love them more. Cute style. Waterproof is great concept. The leather feels great. I couldn’t keep them because every time I touched the leather it showed scratches and scuffs. Maybe the suede would work better?. That would bother me over time, because I like a clean look. And agree with the person who said the packaging was insufficient for the cost of the product. The return bag barely fits over the box and the box arrived crushed at one end. I do my best to return everything in pristine condition, fingers crossed it gets back to the warehouse that way.

Not a comfortable boot

Boots felt good on, but I didn’t like the lace-up as I thought I would.

I loved them but the lacing did not work for me and would not stay tied. They are going back.

Nicely made boots but didn’t work for me. Beautiful boots, unfortunately my 17” calves didn’t fit. I was disappointed to return them but the zipper was almost 2” open ? I had a good laugh.

So excited to have found these great fitting boots for my chicken legs (12” calf). Comfy too. Purchased in black and chocolate brown. Took one star off because the laces come undone to easily, Laces need to be suede.

I have a friend who has this boot and the color is a deeper gray. This one has more tan in it. Love the waterproof aspect and the low heel. I am hoping the original Sharnell boots (not II) will continue to be made in my size and the gray suede so I can have the color I need.

I wear a 9.5 and they fit true-to-size for me. My calves measure about 13.75 inches at the widest and i did have to loosen the laces a little bit at the widest part of my calf. i wear them over jeans - if i was wearing them with a dress or something i probably would not have to loosen the laces. The color is a darker brown with less red than the photos on the site. I thought i got the wrong color at first, but after a quick search i found more accurate photos on other sites. The color difference is the reason I did not give those boots the full amount of stars

LOVE the look of the boot...but the black ones i just received are too small, although the ones i own in different color fit well. Hmmmm.... weird.

The foot part of these boots fits great. I have narrow, low volume size 11 feet and it was a nice surprise that they fit. I also have thin calves (13 inches at the widest part). The calf of the boot is good...not perfect...as they go down to 13 1/2". So they are a tiny bit sloppy but I kept them anyway as they still look good and my chances of finding that perfect fit in the calf is pretty slim. Leather is really nice (I got the chestnut colored ones) and the color is perfect.

Loved the boots but I couldn't zip up around my calf. I actually have small/average calf's. Would have kept the boots if I the calf area was bigger.

Finally found cute riding boots that will fit my small calves! They are comfortable and seem to be well made so far (I've only worn them a few times so far). The only thing I would change would be to have the toe a bit less boxy so they could be dressed up a little. These are great casual looking boots for everyday wear due to the low heel and comfort.

These boots are beautiful and probably very comfortable, but unfortunately I received the wrong size! Love this brand.

I really, really wanted to love these boots. I loved the lace up the back. I was able to customize the fit over jeans or under them. Either worked with my average calves. The materials seemed to be of high quality. The footbed was cushioned, but didn't have the arch support I need. With my inserts (the footbed was not removeable) my toes were getting pinched. These might have stretched out, but at this price I didn't want to chance it. Would definitely have tried a wide sole if it was offered.

I expected to have a "break in" period as I do with most leather footwear, but these boots were comfy from the very start. The size is true, but I imagine there will be some stretching which may make them a little loose. I could not go down a size though. The leather is very heavy duty, but supple. I have skinny calves and finding a 14" shaft is hard, but these could actually be tight! Thank goodness for the laces which make everything perfect.

I loved the look of the boot and the fact it was waterproof. Very comfortable.

Was so excited to get these. Had a bit of trouble zipping them up, but once I adjusted the laces in the back to my calves, no problem. They are snug, warm, stylish and comfortable. Love the animal print lining. I look forward to getting years of wear out of these boots.

I am 24 with sensitive feet and small calves. These shoes are extremely comfortable and fit great! My only complaint is that I can see them wearing down with only one month of use.

Almost perfect! The shaft is a true narrow for a narrow calf, although I wish the shoe were a little wider. Hoping they will stretch around my foot, I give these four stars.

Oh my gosh these are so comfortable!

These boots where just what I had hoped for: fit was great, good for striding the (wet!) streets of Seattle in style and comfort. Plus the laces up the back are really fun, and make it easy to wear with skinny jeans tucked in (difficult with oh-so-many tall leather boots!). Glad I found them!

Beautiful boots, nice quality. Ordered size 9. Ran narrow. Sadly had to return. Next size would be too long.