Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Casual Slip-on Sneaker

Sizing is smaller and tighter than usual for J&M shoes. Didnt fit. Toe box too small.

good shoes

The perfect mens shoe!

one of the two shoes arrived scuffed and scratched

Extremely comfortable even w/out wearing socks! They felt as if I had been wearing them for awhile.

I can always depend on Johnson Murphy shoes, being the right fit and wearing better than average. Its my go to shoe company!

Very nice casual shoe can wear with pants or a pair of shorts. Very comfortable.

Excellent shoe & fit. Very comfortable.

They are already starting to fall apart and its only been a couple of weeks.

Very comfortable shoe and great service from J & M.

I like the style and look of the shoe very much. Like most J&M shoes they are well made. However, this shoe is not as comfortable as I expected therefore the 3-star rating.

Its a great looking show and very stylish. I did have a problem as it was a bit smaller than I expected and used a shoe tree(form) to help stretch the shoe. Once I did that it made the shoe fit much better.

Fit well as I have wide feet. I have another pair in black. I returned only to get the perforated version. Recommend J&M would put removable insoles in these so I could use orthotics.

Love the slip one. This is my second pair. My husband has the brown and blue. Great shoes.

Very comfortable shoe and good fit, but scuffs easily.

Best most comfortable shoe for me. Its my 3rd pair.

Well made shoes.

A very stylish and one of the most comfortable pairs of shoes I have, but they squeak very loud on hard floor surfaces.

The most comfortable pair of shoes I own! I will be ordering another pair in a different color soon. Couldnt be more happier with this purchase!

Fabulous shoe Good look, fit and value. This is my fourth pair over the years and I really like these shoes.

Love the shoes. However, I need to reinsert the liners each time I remove them from my feet. I havent had this problem before with Johnston & Murphy shoes.

I have other J&M pairs of shoes but this time it was bad quality,colors was faded and dull,also material was stiff,overall quality went down significantly then my previous shoes. I returned it and waiting for refund.

Ive had my McGuffeys for over 6 years and the rear tread is just now wearing thin, but the shoe itself still looks great. I use a natural shoe wax on them every few months or so and thats it. Theyve been to several countries and through many weather conditions and I wear them more than any other shoe I own. Theyre worth the investment.

Love the shoes. However, I need to reinsert the liners each time I remove them from my feet. I haven't had this problem before with Johnston & Murphy shoes.

Could always use a bit more arch support.