Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Casual Slip-on Sneaker

The shoes are fantastic. They run about a size too large. If you're a 12 get 11, if 10 get 9, etc. Really great shoes.

Comfortable, good looking, excellent arch support, my third pair of McGuffeys

The comfort and quality of the woven leather is great! We did find that although typically a size 15 in sneakers, my husband needed a smaller size 14 due to this slip-on shoe running large.

My second pair. Always fit perfect Love JM

These are basically comfortable shoes, but for me they are a little tight on the top of the instep. I assume the leather will relax a bit with wear, at least I hope.

I love the shoes. I did not give it 5 stars because they are tight to put them on, but they feel very comfortable otherwise. It is the perfect compromise between sneakers and traditional shoes.

Good fit. Looks good

Great for summer nights out. Very comfortable

Coloring seems Off from the online photos. Color gradient at the tip is much more pronounced and makes it look cheap.

Bought these 5 months ago, they've never stopped squeaking. Sole-to-floor squeaking, not internal slipping. Grip-release of the floor squeaks every single step, Also, much smaller than my last pair of slip on J&M's. I hate them.

found that sizing not satisfied. a 10 is alittle long 9.5 to short, settled for the 10.

Our 4th year of buying these for my teenage sons school uniform dress code. Worth every penny.

Very comfortable good style

Hard to put on

I have owned a few pairs similar to this style and I really like them. This shoe is comfortable and stylish. It is nice but feels a bit more casual. The color I received is actually much lighter than what is shown in the picture. It is also a very soft leather so it scratches easily. That is part of the reason for the 4 star. Largest reason for the 4 star is because the left shoe soul squeaks every time I step.

Great for South Florida

Nice by looking shoes ,looks fantastic with casual clothes

Beautiful quality and style, but runs small. The other pair of shoes I bought with these I had to return to size up. This seems to be the case with all your shoes.

Comfy, adequate support, good fit

Had shipping issues that were my fault, but the customer service was exemplary and helped me fix the problem. Fit and look are great. Incredibly comfortable.

Very comfortable and stylish.

Shoes look very nice, fit perfect.

Very uncomfortable and do not breathe well. I would like to return but theyve been worn once.

I have been buying J&M for many years. Good quality and great looking.

I like the shoe. style. My only suggestion is something more of arc support inside , especially if it's being worn all day long.