Customer Reviews Ariat Sutton H2O

I love love love these boots for comfort, style, the fact that they fit my ample calves even over jeans, and that they are waterproof. They took me all over a recent European vacation where I walked nearly 10 miles a day. I just have ONE complaint. The lug sole is really slippery on wet surfaces. I nearly killed myself on the NYC subway platform where the floors are tiled. I also slipped all over snowy cobblestone streets in Copenhagen. I feel like the indentations aren't deep enough - and the rubber is very smooth instead of having mottling that might make them more slip resistant. I'm going to have to take a file to the soles to roughen them up, and I shouldn't have to do that on $200 boots - but other than that - they are aces.

Contrary to previous reviews, these boots are not intended for riding! They have a zipper on the inside that would badly damage any saddle. These boots are a great waterproof option for the every-day, they are very comfortable and the black leather broke in quicker than expected. Would recommend for an easy, everyday boot!

I had been on the search for a great pair of waterproof boots for awhile. Once I got these in the right size they have been great. The leather has a matte finish making them easy to dress up or down and the design is streamlined and clean. They look great with a pair of black skinny jeans and a sweater, nice enough for the office. I'm sure they'll also be awesome with leggings and a skirt. The leather softens up nicely and though they are a little loose in the heel they don't slip much and are comfortable to walk long distances in.

I have an almost 17” muscular calf and took a chance ordering these boots because of Zappos excellent return policy. I’m a size 11 shoe and usually size up to a 12 in boots but this model stops at an 12. I was able to slip my foot in while wearing cashmere socks which was a happy surprise. This was followed by a smooth zipping experience around my smoke calves - I’m doing a happy dance! They do feel a little stiff which is why I didn’t give comfort & overall a 5, but I plan to wear them indoors since reviews say they will soften with wear. The stretch panel does an amazing job of hugging the calf area with 100% comfort. The stiffness is more in the ankle and I think it’s due to the waterproofing of the suede. I’m a firm believer of less is more so I love the smooth and classic style of the boot which makes my legs look longer and thinner. I’m 5’6” and due to New England’s snowy winters, I wanted a boot that I would wear out with sweater dresses to church and evenings out without compromising on safety and warmth on snowy/icy driveways & sidewalks. The tow area is ample and I can wiggle my toes in comfort which is a first in a size 11 boot for me. For reference, I wear an 11.5 in Blondo and 12 wide in La Canadienne. Thank you, Zappos for the faster then expected delivery in light of Covid. I’ve been a happy customer for 20 years!

These boots were very uncomfortable. They're riding boots, not necessarily casual fashion boots so I'm not too surprised. The area behind the heel is very stiff an uncomfortable just walking around in my house. I also think that for $200 they could use leather the entire way around, instead of manmade material in the back on the uppers.

These were pretty comfortable for me right of the bat- good support, though the calves are narrow which luckily works for me. No blisters on the first few wears either.

Really love these boots. They were a little stiff the first time I wore them, but by the second wearing, they softened up and now are super comfortable. They are also warm and have good traction on the ice. I live in Minneapolis and it is not only cold, but very icy. These boots make the cut - they are awesome! I am a size 10, am always a size 10, and unlike some of the other reviews, I did not go down a size, but stuck with my usual size 10. They fit true to size. Highly recommend these boots.

The Best *Go Anywhere, Do Anything* Boot: I bought these to replace a pair of boots that I love, but I have worn the soles out. I think I bought 5 different pairs (online)--including some for $700! These are exactly what I was looking for--VERSATILITY! These boots are super comfortable. The quality is amazing. The fit is superb! The best part--they are functionally amazing! Waterproof, comfortable fit, quality materials, and stylish (dress up or down--tshirt/jeans or skinnies/cute top). The stretchy back allows for a custom fit. Note: They are a little stiff, at first, but that's to be expected from leather! In a few weeks, these will be broken in, and added to my daily (and/or rainy) attire! :) Love you, Ariat!!! Thanks for the upgraded replacement! The old boot and new boot is shown in the pics, for comparison.

I am so excited about these boots! I'm a runner and have "athletic" calves- approx. 15.5 inches, and these are one of the first pairs of boots that fit me perfectly. I've tried wide-calf boots only to have to return them because they are way too wide and look like pirate boots. The stretch panel on the back of these boots makes them fitted and most important, comfortable. They are easy to put on and look cute. I'm also happy that they are water proof as winter in Chicago is wet.

I really liked the look of these boots as they’re less dressy. The waterproofing gives Them a very matte finish. I normally wear a 7.5M and that’s what I got. Perfect length and slightly wide. Initially I did not like the stiffness of the shaft but the leather part is softening with wear. Hopefully the elastic area will as well. I’ve only had them a week. I ordered these boots over others bc the shaft circumference was smaller. My calf is 13.5” around and these leave enough room for comfort with jeans tucked in. Have rec’d several compliments.

these are gorgeous boots on every level. the leather is sublime and waterproof to boot. the fit my legs like a glove. i have athletic calves, but not huge, so the "wide calf" boots are often toooo big and the regular boots are often too tight. annoying! these give just the right amount and fit great upon the first wearing, i am sure they will fit even better over time. thank you for making such a GREAT BOOT!

Warm, comfy, and waterproof! Great for walking around on rainy days. Top quality Ariat leather and craftsmanship. They look better with age and will work as rainboots for years.

LOVE these boots. Love the English 'riding' style. Quality and fit are superior and as expected from Ariat. I have an athletic calf and always have trouble finding a tall boot that fits comfortably, especially with jeans tucked. The combination leather/synthetic allow for ease of zipping and stretch to fit with or without pants. Dark colored YKK zipper blends seamlessly with the black boot. Waterproofing is the cherry on top. Look forward to wearing these fall/winter seasons.

I have many styles and makes of boots that don't work for my aging feet. I took a chance on these because of the height of the heel and room in the toes. They work very well for me plus they are well constructed and good-looking.

These are great riding boots! Taller than my last pair of h2O’s. They fit perfectly and I have a bit wider calf.

These boots are awesome! Super chic and comfortable. Love the heavier tread on the soul. Excellent gripping on wet surfaces. Like other Ariat boots, virtually zero break-in time. I normally wear a size 9 and in Ariat, I almost always get 8.5. So I recommend CHOOSE HALF SIZE SMALLER.

I absolutely love these boots!! They are beautiful!! They were comfortable right out of the box!!! The color of the brown is perfect!! You will not be disappointed with this purchase.

Love these boots! Skinny around my calves - perfect!

Love these. Ordered an 11, fits great and is super comfortable. Would keep them, but for the price I just don't think the material will be great for everyday riding boots. Seems like it would collect sand and dirt. Going with the other pair of Ariat's I ordered with a leather foot.

I love these boots so much, I'm thinking of ordering a backup pair. They're simple, but well constructed, beautiful leather uppers, and a practical but stylish heel. Shaft expands if you need it to, but silhouette stays slim due to elastic side panels. I ordered two different pairs of knee high boots from Zappos, this was the first box I opened, and I didn't even bother opening the other box. Love, love, love.

Fit great! I ordered a 1/2 size up to accommodate arch inserts and thick socks, and to leave room for swelling since these are all-day walking boots. I wore them all over New Orleans for a weekend and they were great. I have thin calves and usually boots are too loose for me there, but these were snug but very comfortable, and flattering! I plan to wear them all over the Houston Rodeo next month - cowboy boots do not work for me for all day wear on pavement. Highly recommend for doing a lot of walking with a lot of style.

I usually wear an 8.5, but ordered the 8 as suggested. They fit well and the look was what I wanted, but when I walked they pinched at one of my ankles. I thought it would probably soften with time and had also tried a very similar looking boot from Clark’s. I ended up returning these and keeping the Clark’s. Hopefully over time, it was the right decision.

For the most part I really like these boots. They are warm and have good traction in the snow. They are a bit narrow though which is a bummer. They are also stiff. I am hoping they will soften the more I wear them.