Customer Reviews Ariat Sutton H2O

These boots are not only stylish, they are also comfortable! So far I’ve traveled with them, the only pair of shoes I took on a quick 2-day turnaround trip. We did quite a bit of walking, these boots did not disappoint. Highly recommended.

I initially ordered a size 8 which is my typical size but these were too large. I returned them for a 71/2 and the fit is perfect with room for a significant pair of socks. The shoe appears to be well made and I love the look. They feel so comfortable and supportive and the sole feels sturdy.

Love love love. They broke in right away, and fit perfectly. Best boots I've ever owned, hand down.

The boots are nice and they are true to size. However, I feel that for the price the shaft should be all leather, and not half elastic. Also, these boots wrinkle at the ankle which I do not like at all. I may have to bite the bullet and go back to Frye boots which are all leather and in my experience don't wrinkle at the ankle.

I found these to be very comfortable. A little loose in the heel but I wear them with tights so far so maybe with thicker socks that looseness will go away (but no blisters or discomfort when I wear them with tights) They were a bit higher than I thought they would be but I wanted them to wear with dresses and skirts so the height works. The quality seems really good. I need a warm boot I can walk miles in, in a skirt. These boots fit the bill. I liked the look of them and decided to give them a try knowing I could return if I had to. I think they're great boots.

I really love these boots. They are very stiff at first, not uncomfortable, just stiff. After wearing them around they are breaking in nicely. It was a little difficult getting my foot in at first, but again, over time it has gotten easier. I have athletic calves, I sometimes have to buy wide shaft boots. These fit really nicely, the back has enough stretch to accommodate my calf while still maintaining a sleek look. I normally wear a 7.5 and the 7 fit great.

Difficult to get on at the instep even with the zipper. Once on, foot a little big, but mostly too wide (only at the top) for my leg. Well made boots if they fit you.

Wow, these are so well made! They really put lot of thought into the construction of the boot and I think they would last forever. However, I had to return them because I felt that for the price of the boot there is too much of the stretchy material and I would prefer little bit more leather or suede. Also they didn't seem very warm. Had to return them sadly.

I wear a size 11.5 and the 11's were fine, although I tried them on without socks or tights. They were uncomfortably tight by the calf even though they were able to be zipped, I think it was the stiffness of the boot rather than the fit. It was not what I was looking for, so I'm returning.

They were fairly comfortable. But I didn't like the elastic back. It is especially noticeable in the brown color way (the elastic is jarring compared to the leather). And, the material combination (elastic and possibly lining), felt uncomfortably hot. Not the kind that would make you warm in the cold, but overheat in normal conditions. Therefore, giving 4 stars. Because, otherwise, it's a relatively nice looking boot.

Returning bc they burn small and are hard to get on bc they’re too stiff

It's a very casual looking boot. Good looking overall, but the elastic just made it more casual than I'm looking for. Also, the elastic on the brown is quite pronounced. I preferred the black color way. As for fit - while it was perfect in width and length, the girth was too big for me which caused it to look baggy across the top where the arch is.

Boot is true to size. I am a 7 and I can wear this 7 with a medium-thick sock. They are a teensy bit tight on my calf, but I think they will stretch over time.

These boots fit me very well and I loved the look but seemed very stiff when walking. I seemed to push me on the back of my ankle.

The calf was too tight and the foot bed was too large. Had to send them back.

I had a pair of Ariat shows years ago that were so well made, attractive, and comfortable. I was very disappointed in the Sutton boots. To me they looked and felt cheap. The stretch material is stiff and does not blend well with the suede part. For $200 I think the quality should be better.

These boots were so uncomfortable, stiff like cardboard. The shaft was very narrow, squeezed my calves, which are average sized. Not a great boot, definitely not worth $200.