Customer Reviews TOMS Paxton Water-Resistant Slip-Ons

These are really cute and look so inviting with the soft lining. I wanted to like them, but they had to go back. I tried a pair in my normal size and also a half size up. Neither were comfortable. They felt stiff, boxy, and tight across the width. These booties may work for people with really narrow feet.

A little too narrow for me in the toe box - I have wide feet. I also didn't like the zig-zag stitching across the top as it would have looked nicer with a plain stitch or none at all.

Very cute, sumptuous suede and soft lining, but incredibly narrow. Had to return them.

I ordered two sizes - the recommended size was too small, but my usual size was fine. Only two problems - they’re a bit narrow right at the ball of my foot, and the leather loop on the heel (used to help pull them on) broke on my second wearing. A bit disappointing, but I’ll see it back on and keep them.

For my foot, this shoe was too wide in the arch area (center) and too narrow in the toe area.

Very stiff and hard to walk with. Doesn’t seem to have a good grip on bottom sole. The style is sort of cute but awkward at certain angle. Had to return.

Cute shoes! Super narrow and overall too small. I’m a 5.5 in slip on Toms. They are so uncomfortable and even though they’re narrow they were super clunky and felt like clown shoes on my feet. Kinda hate them. Too bad.

I had high hopes for these. They are cute but not as comfy as I hoped and a little tight. Order half size up.

I didn’t notice at first but after only a few hours in them, they became extremely uncomfortable, rubbing on the sides and backs of my ankles/heel. I planned on buying a second pair but not now.

Felt like I pronated.

I am a tall girl with size 12 feet. I am very self-conscious about shoes that make my feet look even larger than true size. These definitely made them look larger and were very masculine in a size 12. I think it 's because of the plain, flat top. Bummed to have to return because they were comfortable, but nobody liked them on me.

I wanted to love these shoes, but I didn't. They're cute....but SO uncomfortable. The left shoe feels slightly bigger than the right. The right shoe has a seam on the inside that rubs near my little toe. I've tried to wear these to work twice now and my feet were killing me at the end of the day.

These felt really clunky, and were hard to get on and off. Wanted to love them, but no such luck.

These are definitely pink. They look like a light tan pictured but they are pink

Great looking shoe but runs narrow

Cuter in the pic but I would have kept them if they fit. They are a bit narrow in the toe box and make my Morton’s Nueroma zing. Back they go.

It was comfortable but I thought the top part of the shoe made it look a little funny. Returned them.

I was shocked by these. The color was way more pinkish to me which immediately turned me off and I was shocked they didn’t feel super comfortable. I thought there’d be a lot more cushion around the ankle.

Ordered an 11, couldn’t even walk in them they were so small. Received the 12 today and they are way too big. Unfortunate because I like Toms. Sadly these won’t work.

very hard to put on without zipper

These shoes are significantly narrower than expected.

Really wanted to like Reese. They appeared to be exactly what I wanted. I typically order a half size larger in Tom’s and that was true here also. The shoes do run narrow though. At first I thought I would just wear them around home to see if the fit would relax but then it seemed like I could feel the entire side seams at the sole and decide to return them.

wasnt as cute or comfortable as i expected. Toms is a popular brand, I expected more

A very pretty shoe. Good quality leather and design. Unfortunately, a very narrow shoe, even for a normal width. I had to return it. The brand needs to redesign the shape of the footbed and make it more “normal”. This looks like the slippers that have no shape. Too bad!

I usually wear a 7.5 in Tom's and have a narrow foot. I read these ran small, so I ordered an 8. The 8 was too sloppy and loose, so I exchanged them for a 7.5. The 7.5 is so tight and rubs on my heel (with super thin socks even) that I'm returning them immediately. I was really excited for these because they are cute and the fur is soft, but I'm out of size options unfortunately.