Customer Reviews TOMS Paxton Water-Resistant Slip-Ons

As many have noted, these are really cute and unique booties. They seem very well made and I love the rich suede with warm cushion-y lining. Sadly, even though I never wear a wide width shoe, I also had the issue with them being narrow at the forefoot so had to return. I have other Toms with a similar sole and they fit fine. I think it may be the thicker lining that make these too narrow in that area.

These are very cute shoes. Unfortunately something is not correct in the heel of the left shoe in the pair I received. These is a hard ridge that became painful as I wore these inside my house.

Runs large, returning for smaller size

These are comfortable and TTS, however, the styling on a size 91/2-10 makes feet look huge so sadly returning.

Loved the style of these, just felt too narrow in the width.

I bought these because I usually have good luck with Toms when I want to wear my orthotics. These don't work quite as well with my custom orthotics but they are pretty comfortable on their own. They are nice because they are really easy to pull on to walk my dog, and they are waterproof so I can wear them when it's snowy.

I'm glad I read the reviews before buying. I purchased a half size larger than usual, and the fit is good (still a bit narrow in the ball of my foot, but not uncomfortable). These are really cute - the perfect casual shoe for times when you might otherwise wear a sneaker!

These are a bit narrow, so if you have a wide foot, I wouldn’t buy them. They are super cute and I’m gonna keep them. I’m hoping with some wear they will loosen up.

Love them!

Nice TOMS. Not quite as comfy as the originals, but seem to be breaking in after a week’s use.

I am a true size 7. I don't have a wide foot and rarely have problems with shoes feeling too narrow...that being said, these felt painfully narrow across the top. It's too bad because they are cute. Definitely not for me!

The left shoe slipped off my heel while the right shoe did not. They felt great in the toe box without socks, but with socks on (to help with the heel slipping) the sides of my feet were rubbing the seam of the shoe which was painful. Wanted to love these but have to return! They need to be a little wider in the toe box for me.

They are very nice, only reason I returned them was because of the colour. It was just far to light for me. But they felt super comfy!

I usually wear an 8, but the True Fit tool suggested that I order an 8.5 and that was correct. The toe box is definitely a bit narrow, so I am hoping that they stretch a bit. Due to that, I would have never been able to wear an 8. I love the style and the comfort.

These are very cute shoes, but maybe it's just the shape or size of my foot, but the shoes pull my ankle socks down when walking in them. They are kind of heavy shoes. Which is good in a way because they are probably very well made and durable but bad if you want to wear ankle socks with them.

Super cute shoes. Love wearing.

Super cute and good quality. They definitely run narrow and I'm not sure how much they would stretch. I considered going a half size up but I think they would have been too narrow for me. I always wear a medium width shoe.

Very cute and overall comfortable. Only discomfort is the heel rubs. Have to wear a band aid or moleskin to keep from blistering.

I can wear these shoes for work, walking the dog, casual night out. They are so versatile. Love them.

I ordered two of the different colors and materials. Ordered the navy quilted and the forged gray suede with fur trim. I kept the forged gray only because I liked the white soles on them. The blue quilted has a brownish sole which reminds me of house shoes. I could wear the quilted ones longer (I live in the Houston area) but just didn’t care for the look. Love the forged gray ones though. I always wear a 7.5 in toms and these were true to size.

I wanted this keep these but unfortunately they were too narrow in the toe box. The color was great and cute.

Would keep these navy boot styled shoe for certain BUT the ankle, heel areas were too wide for me! Too bad! They felt perfect otherwise.

I like the shoes, and if I was wearing them without socks, I would mark them as true to size. As is, I think they are more "cold weather" shoes so they are a bit tight. I'm keeping them, but will need to wear them with thin socks (which isn't the first thing I choose in cold weather). I would recommend a half size up if you want to wear with normal socks.

I wear a true size 11 and this felt one size too small. Too bad because they are cute and I think they’d be comfortable! Too bad they don’t make them larger!

Not enough arch support. Cute shoe. Love slip-ons