Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

Recommendation to order up a 1/2 size was helpful, could be a little more supportive but worked fine for a short time

I have these boots and love them more than any. They are very warm in WI winters (way too hot for inside), extremely comfortable, and have the lowest most barefoot profile around for proper balance and stability. That said, I bought the size wide for my daughter, and they are not wide enough. Standard wide shoes always fit well, but these still bind in the instep. If you have average to narrow feet, these are the best. If they're wide, you might want to keep looking.

Keeps feet very warm in the snow and has a bouncy and cushioned sole. Would get 5 stars but runs narrow and is a little bit of work to get on.

Very cute!!! My only complaint is that they run very small. I think its because of the heavy lining. I normally wear an 8 or 8.5, so I got a 9. Its still a little too snug, so I might exchange.

They do tend to run small or more narrow. Size up 1 ! Extremely comfortable and warm.

Like the boots but they definitely run small. Will be sending them back and reordering a size bigger. When reviews say order st least a size up -do so or you will be stuck with paying a return fee!!!!

A very nice boot. Comfortable. I did expect the bottom to be a bit heavier as I was thinking of using them for cross country skiiing, but not sure I will do that now. Love the look while wearing them.

I was so happy when my boots came in the mail as I am traveling up north where it's snowing. I needed a warm and waterproof boot. When I got them I tried them on and couldn't even get my foot into them. They are by no means for wide feet. I tried them on without socks and ordered a wide because I was going to wear socks. Also there should be a loop in the back to hold on while putting your foot into them. I am very upset as I am going to have to return them. They are also thinnly made so I don't know how they are insulated or warm either.

Very warm and extremely comfortable. May run a little small as the half size bigger than my usual size fits perfectly.

Really comfortable and warm. They do run small even though i got half a size bigger.

4 starts only because it doesn't fit. Didn't have a chance to wear for long at all...too small in toe box (I have bunions) but wanted to be able to keep it. Very comfortable for a winter boot, love the looks of it and Khaki is a great color... but would need a wide and it's not available in my size in any colors. It almost worked but not quite.

way too small, but if you size up (both length and width), they're nice

Super cute, and comfortable. They run a little bit small, so I would recommend sizing up one size.

Ordered a 9 wide, typically closer to an 8 or 8.5 wide. For a wide they still seem to narrow. Live in Alaska and wanted something grippy during walks. I ended up keeping them but think the fit can be improved.

Very comfortable boot, stylish, light weight but very warm. Good traction in snow, haven't tried on icy pavement yet. Bought my usual size in a wide, but it was a very close fit, not wide at all and could have gone up a half size. They fit okay with mid weight socks; fortunately they are very warm and don't need heavy socks or they would be too tight. Haven't had them long enough to test the waterproof quality.

Great product in terms of quality - however it is too narrow.

The boot runs small, In reading other reviews I sized up a half size. I wear a heavy sock and The boot will keep your feet warm. Not very much arch support so I put arch inserts in. Over all it is a keeper. I would recomend it.

This is a great boot for running errands and going to work when it's snowy. Good traction other than glare ice. Warm but not Arctic wear. It is exactly what I needed.

Based on the comments here I bought a bigger sizer, 8.5 instead of 7.5. It fits perfectly

So cute, lightweight and warm. Runs a bit narrow.

I read the comments before I purchased and sized up to a 10, I'm normally a 9. When I received them I could've sized about to about a 10.5 but they still fit. They are pretty comfortable and seem pretty durable so far.

Looks great, material quality great, but it runs to small, go at least 1 size extra if you plan to move your toes and use socks.