Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

Comfy boot keeps feet warm. The only thing that needs improvement is the fake fur at top. It comes off in pieces and looks disturbing on the floor.

Shoes are very comfy especially for people with wide feet.

Unfortunately the size I got was too small so I need to exchange for a different size. They do seem like they would be comfortable and warm in the right size

Runs so small! I usually wear a size 8 but needed size 10 in these boots. Very cute. Quality seems good. Have not worn them in the snow yet.

Cute but felt a half size too small to me. Would size up.

These replacement boots are as light and warm as the originals, but not as supple. I hope with time they will be more flexible. I wore the last pair 3 seasons.

Warm boots, good fit, cute! Rub a bit on the heel but have only worn 1 time.

I sized up half a size and these were way too small I could barely get my foot in! They seem like a good pair of shoes just run super small and are pretty slender width wise

These boots are lightweight and comfortable to walk around in. I like that they keep my feet dry. They do seem to be a bit narrow, so I sized up one size and I also got the wide to allow room for thicker socks.

These are nice, but like many others, I ordered 1 to 1.5 sized up, and they fit. They feel comfortable. I haven't worn them in winter weather yet. normally wear an 8.5 or 9, and I got a 9.5. Seem like they will be ok, but could have even gone with a 10.

They're very warm and cozy. I will be returning though because there is absolutely no arch support, and that became uncomfortable even just walking around my house. They're also quite narrow.

Overall the boots are almost as good as my old pair. I bought a pair of boots in December of 2014 that I wore until I bought this pair. The new boots are very similar but the heel construction is slightly more narrow. Enough that I debated going back to my old pair but not so much that I did. I wish Columbia would lean into utilitarian outdoor, when they focus too much in style you loose ,practically. For several years I was unable to replace my old boots because the cut of the boot that year was too narrow in the tie box and heel.

I liked the boot itself and would have kept them had it not been for the sizing issue. I ordered a half size up and they were still too small. I think another half size up would have fit. I can't speak to the durability or warmth of the boot since I had to return them.

Size wise: I have overall narrow feet but wide where people usually have bunions. Based on reviews I went with this wide boot 1 size bigger than I normally wear. I think I could have gotten away with just a half size bigger for length. I think I'm between regular fit and wide and could probably go with either for width. Aesthetics wise: they're pretty cute! Comfort wise: The soles were comfortable for my short test, but the fabric upper was weird. When I tied the laces, they dug through the fabric and put odd pressure points along the tongue. No matter how I rearranged the laces and how I tied it, it was uncomfortable on the tops of my feet and the front of my ankles when I walked. They're soft on the inside and warm from what I could tell. But honestly, I'm returning for below reason, so I never tested them in elements (only walking briefly in my house). Function wise: Probably fine for walking to school or work, but I wouldn't try and be adventurous in these. I have 'weak ankles' and if I started to slip on some ice or stepped on an uneven snow mound or uneven pavement, the ankles would go and I'd bite it, hard. There just isn't enough structure for me in the upper Durability/quality: Seems like they're well made, but I haven't tested them for durability

Very warm, keep my feet dry in snow and puddles. Pretty cute for the performance quality. This is my 2nd pair.

Nice cozy, lightweight, and waterproof boots. They do run small! I always wear 6 1/2 so I got the 7 and it fits well. Be aware these have a very narrow fit, in addition to running small lengthwise. All that said, I do like them so far. The sole is grippy on ice and snow, and the faux fur around the collar is nice and cozy. They are really cute too. Deducting a star just because Columbia needs to get their act together with their sizing.

Runs very small, size up at least 1-1.5 sizes. Had to return to get a bigger size.

Runs about 1/2 size small so order up. Found them to be waterproof but not very warm. My feet were cold in the car before being exposed to any kind of weather. You will need some warm socks underneath to keep your feet warm.

Great boot for running quick errands or anything casual. These are not made for anything other than casual activity. Size up half a size at least.