Customer Reviews Columbia Minx Shorty III

Very comfy and actually fit my wide feet. I had to order a 1/2 size up as they were a little snug.

I ordered an 8 1/2 wide even though I normally wear an 8 wide. The box says 8 1/2W but the tag in the boot does not have a W following the size. If these are actually a wide then they run narrow. If I didn't size up they wouldn't have fit at all. They are snug accross the toe box with a thin sock. They are warm and mostly comfy. Hopefully they will stretch in time as I really like them.

I loved these boots! They were the right size, wide, and the right price! However when I got them and tried them out I found no arch support. So I had to return them. If arch support isn't something you need then I HIGHLY recommend these boots! I'm sad they didn't work out.

A nice thick pair of socks will not work unless you buy a half size up. They run small.

Cute but runs small. Ordered a larger size hopefully they fit.

These have changed from the original version. Plus is there was a seam right at the widest part of the foot on both sides of the og that did split eventually--no longer a seam there so it shouldn't split. These are still just as warm and comfortable, and i would assume as weather resistant. Downsides are that they run smaller. I wear a 10.5 and the og were a bit roomy for thick socks. This time i bought an 11 and wouldn't be able to do that. Also, the og had a loop at the back to pull the boot on that has been removed with this version.

The color is super cute and they're really warm. I'd suggest going at least a half size up. I usually wear a 10, and after reading other reviews I ordered a 10.5, but I probably should've gone up to an 11 so I could wear thicker socks more comfortably. Overall, these boots are great and I can't wait to wear them in the snow!

These boots are very cute and comfortable but i ended up returning them becuase they are very narrow in the toes and i have wide feet

These boots are amazing! They feel more like tennis shoes than boots. Graceful and comfortable, but still sporty and all terrain. The only issue i had, and why i gave 4 stars instead of 5, is that they were far too warm for my feet. They are intended to be warm...snow boots, right? But my feet are my body thermometers. When they get too warm, I'm miserable. If your feet are always cold or heat isn't an issue - get these boots!

I ordered one size up. I am usually 7, but as what I have read from past reviews, this particular boot needs a size up. So I got an 8 which is the only available size for this shoe. I got lucky and it fits right. Enough room for thick socks. I will definitely order a size up for this kind of winter boots. My feet isnt wide so I like the way this boots feel. I ordered this during summertime by the way so I haven't used it yet. The way it looks, this boot has good quality.

Good quality, warm. Runs small wish I would be gone up a size

They look really nice, very good price and comfortable, I will 5 starts if the size was accurate, since they run small. I would recommend to order 1 more size. Example: if you are size 8, better to order size 9, other than that are wonderful.

My most favorite boot!! Even on concrete all day, my feet don't hurt. Decided to buy 4 pairs. I am set for boots for a long time. Warm, waterproof and so light. Nearly feels like a slipper. They run a tiny bit small. But once I broke them in, they fit perfectly.

I really like these boots. They check all the boxes; warm, waterproof and stylish. I thought I ordered my normal size 8.5 but turns out I ordered size 9. They are a pretty snug size 9. I don't think I could wear really thick socks with them. So definitely order a 1/2 to a full size larger. I think 9.5 would have been ideal for me.

Very comfortable! Great for hiking in the frozen tundra this crazy winter. Kept my feet warm and dry.

boots are nice and well done, but for the size you need 1 size bigger, my wife both 7.5 her size and was uncomfortable, so she need 8.5

I love the style of these boots! The only thing is that they are a bit to tight on top of the toe and top part of foot after sending back my normal size for a bigger size still a bit to tight

I am really happy with these boys. They fit well (I'm typically a 7.5 in shoes but I bought an 8 and that was the right choice), they are warm and sturdy and send like they'll last a long time. Just a couple things- I expected the color to be sort of a cranberry, but it's more raspberry (a more purply pink than red). I really like them anyway but it's something to note. Also I wish they had a loop or something to grab on the back- they're a little tough to pull on and it would be nice to have some help. Other than that, they're perfect!

I typically fit between and 8.5 and 9, so I always get 9s to be safe. These run really Small. I probably would of ended up getting a 10.