Customer Reviews KEEN Presidio II

I wanted so badly to wear these shoes! My foot measures a 7.5 but I ordered a size 8 because with closed-toe shoes, I often prefer the extra room. These were like compression shoes! I'm so disappointed. I've already returned them but I ordered a size 9 and maybe those will fit? (The 9s haven't arrived yet.) Everything else about them — the color, the look, the style — was exactly as described.

I'm not sure what Keen is doing with their quality construction but these shoes no longer fit right. I have a pair of Presidio's I bought over a year ago and love them. Decided to get another. I bought the "orange" presidio's and had to return them because the right shoe was a whole size bigger then the left and the left was not very comfortable. So I returned them and decided to try Presidio II. My old ones are size 9 so bought the 9 which fit but the heel kept coming out of the shoe, so I tighten string even more, which helped a little but the arch, was very uncomfortable; it caused pains in my feet. So sadly I'm returning them. I really really like these shoes but don't know if these are defected shoes or Keen is just doing short cuts in their constructions because a 9 from the same shoe a year ago, should be exactly the same as a 9 now. (Because I'm 0-2 in trying new Keen's.) They still feel sold and well made, from the outside, so that has not changed, but the way they feel, inside, the construction is definitely different. And not for the better.

Very narrow toe box and really pinched my feet.

I wanted to love these shoes, but the toe box is very narrow for a Keen shoe, and the heel is too wide so my foot slips out of them. I purchased these and the original Presidio shoes, and the originals fit so much better. The presidio II is a cute she but sadly does not fit like most Keen shoes fit. If you need a standard toe box, and have a wider heel, these may fit you well.

I love my Presidios. I thought these would fit the same, but they don't. They are narrower with a smaller toe box. I have worn Keens for years, so if possible, please offer the original Presidio in these colors. I especially loved the silver birch. Back they go.

I have had this same shoe before but this time it did not fit. The cut was higher and much larger than my last pair

Terrible they have an off gassing smell and the “leather” is unyielding. They are not as comfortable as the 10 previously wore pairs, they were the only shoe I wore for 20 years. I’m going to see if I can resole my one older pair.

I don't know about the size because the material was so stiff I couldn't get my foot into the shoe - a size I have worn for years. I had an old pair of Keens that looked like this pair so I was hopeful and then disappointed.

The tongue of this shoe was about 1/2" longer than other similar-style Keen shoes that I love! That didn't work out for me; pinched in the front.

The tongue of this shoe is longer than my old ones. That's a deal breaker, becauses they now pinch the top of my foot.

I didn't bother to try them on - Ugliest. Shoes. Ever.

In the past I have purchased several pairs of Keen shoes and was very pleased with the fit and the material they were made with. I was very disappointed with the new pair I received. The toe box was narrower and the material they are made of is very stiff. Very disappointed!!

Super disappointed in these after having bought 3 pairs of Keen Presidios previously. These are much narrower in the toe box and arch, and much, much stiffer than the design of 2-3 years ago.

I am disappointed with the narrower toe box of this new version of the Presidio shoe. I knew it would be uncomfortable to wear from the moment I put it on. Normally Keens feel great right away! The prior version of Presidio was wider and accommodated my wide foot. I have been buying this shoe for three years but now have to find something else. I still like the look but that does not help when I can not wear them!

I ordered these woman shoes since they don't come in my size for men. Big mistake! The arch seems way too long and as a result the shoe feels entirely uncomfortable. The color is also lighter than I expected.. I was exited about finally getting a pair of keen's, now Im disappointed...