Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Packer

I am usually a 7 in boot but the 6.6W fit me better. I have a thin heel and wide toebox so I think the wife allowed me to size down a half size. The tassels touch the ground which is a tad gross sometimes. The leather is buttery soft and thin. I returned them but after trying them on I think they’d be comfortable enough to wear without hurting but I wouldn’t say they are super cushion-y.

I am normally a 7 in boots but the 6.5W fit me better overall. The tassels on the zippers do touch the floor a tad which may be gross in a public restroom. The leather is extremely soft and the footbed is comfortable enough.

I ordered these in 3 colors, 3 different sizes, so Id get the right fit. The green is beautiful, the deep autumnal "paprika" is amazing and versatile. Sadly the only color in my size was the saddle. Trying to decide if I'll keep them after being glamoured by the red ones?? They are soft, comfortable and well made. True to size. Great bootie

I am usually a 7 in boots but the 7 had too much room in the back, ie my husband notified it looked funny when I tried them on for him. Since I have a wife toebox I tried the 6.5W and there was still plenty of room in the length plus the extra toebox space. The material was soft and the zippers convenient. I do think depending how you are standing the zippers may touch the ground which may gross some people out.

Boots were cute but color was not as not as pictured. Red ones were more brownish. Fit was fine though. Sent back.

I probably should have gotten a smaller size, but they look good and work with an insole.

I like the styling of this Sam Edelman Packer boot, but it does run a bit narrow and actually was uncomfortable on my foot. Pretty boot, but sadly have to return it for fit.

Cute style but a little big. I kept them anyway.

These were cute, but nothing special. I was drawn to the color online, thinking they would be a nice accent, but in person, the color was too drab for me. I didn't want red, but more of a the name "Paprika", but to me they looked closer to a rust color.

These shoes were very cute, and I wish they fit better. I have a wide foot, and the 8W were still a little narrow. I tried going up a size but that was too big.

These booties were almost perfect and I'm so sad to return them. As others have noted, they are just a little narrow in width at the toe box and don't come in a W in my size. The next 1/2 size up was a little too big in the heel - I tried with various socks to see if I could make either work but at the end of the day, will be returning. otherwise comfortable, the leather is super soft, and worth a try!

I REALLY wish these would have worked for me, as they're absolutely beautiful boots! I ordered a 10W at first hoping that the wide would accommodate my wide toe box, but they were too long and the heel was far too wide. The 9.5W was a better fit, but the heel was still too wide and with the slick insole, my foot was slipping around a lot. The slick insole also caused my toes to want to jamb forward into the still-not-wide-enough toe box area. I even purchased some socks with gripping material on the soles in the hopes that they would help keep my foot stable, but it just wasn't going to work. What a bummer for me.

I'm on the fence with these. They are nice, comfortable basic boot, especially if you like the Sam Edelman Petty's. I actually found the wide width to work perfectly, however, they ran very long and if I decide to keep them I will have to try down half a size. I also think I want something with a bit more detail but I might be back for these! I would also be concerned how the leather would hold up to scuffs and such.

I loved the look and fit of the boot but after two short wearings, the toe appeared shiny as if the suede had worn away. The lighted pair I ordered, wasn't so obvious.

I have this same shoe in a different color so I purchased the same size but this one fit much tighter and was too small.

The boots are cute and the color is perfect but I ordered a 1/2 size bigger and the shoes are still too narrow.

I really loved the way these boots looked, they fit great (TTS), I liked the material and color. I got the Asphalt Velutto and it has this great distressed look that I love but I agree with other reviewers that said it was like walking on concrete. A few adjustments and these boots would be perfect: softer sole, more grip on the bottom, and why are they so loud? I have hard wood floors and it sounded like I was stomping around in 10 pound boots. I really hate that so back they go.

Narrow boot and I never wear wide shoes. Like the Macon and Morgan best, but they run narrow as well.

I like not love the look of these boots so I decided to keep them. I’ve worn them a few times and realized they’re poorly designed. With every step you take you’re pulling the front flap forward which tugs on the zippers causing them to unzip constantly! I would return them if I hadn’t worn them. Wouldn’t recommend for the hefty price.

I have these same boots in leather and oddly, the same size in the gray suede were too small. Great boots though!