Customer Reviews Frye Melissa Button 2

Finally the perfect every day boot

Bought suggested sz. . 1/2sz too big but fixing with insoles.

I am so disappointed! They sent me the wrong color! They were too big even tho review suggested to size up & super difficult to pull on! Sent back!

These are beautiful for the sale price but the sizing is off. I ordered my usual size 9 but they were way too big. I couldve returned for an 8. 5 but FRYE charges a $12 return/exchange fee so I just decided to return and not risk having to return a second pair. Wish stores carried more inventory so you wouldnt have to go through the whole mailing/return fees.

these are really cute but if you have bigger legs like me, choose the wide calf so it is easier to put on and off. the leather is very soft.

Great looking boot , perfect fit, look forward to wearing it and I appreciate the sales reps at Frye, helpful, professional and most were friendly and patient

I do not recommend these boots. I do not know what has happened with Frye boots bc Ive always loved them but the different colors sizing is inconsistent. Also a black pair the left foot fit and the right did not. Returned all 3 pairs

The boot itself is great quality and very visually appealing but I went up a size and unfortunately I still cannot fit either of the boots I purchased!

Still wearing my Melissa boots from 10 years ago. Have had them resoled twice as Ive walked miles and miles in them. Decided to get another pair in redwood to broaden my wardrobe. Take care of them and theyll last forever!

Gorgeous boots but impossible to get on and off. I had to return them because they were unwearable.

I bought the melissa button a couple of years ago and had no issues. Ordered my regular size and it fit perfectly. Despite reading the reviews about how this boot is not the same, I thought it would somehow be different for me. I was mistaken. I even ordered a half size up just in case, but I could still not get my heel into this boot. The quality is just not the same and this is not the same boot as the previous Melissa. Frye, please go back to making high craftmanship boots, this is a huge downgrade from what you used to be.

Great fit and style. Super comfortable.

One of the boots was scratched so I am returning them for a replacement.

I received my boots with a scratch on the front. Had to return

I love it- just what I have been looking for. I just need to change my size and it will be perfect!!

Exactly what I was looking for.

These are beautiful, but they are so hard to put on. The inner lining wasnt stitched properly and it makes it even harder for that one boot. I was going to send them back and decide to give it time to break them in.

Received these as a gift for my Birthday. They did not fit and were already scratched. The circumference of the calf actually measures about an inch smaller than is listed online. Frye was not accommodating or kind with any kind of return or even exchange for store credit when the boots didnt fit. With the holidays coming up its really difficult to plan ahead with a strict 30 day return policy especially when the website states different measurements than what the boots actually are. This was such a disappointing product and experience for a company who takes so much pride in their products.

High quality, great fit, soft leather I am extremely pleased with my purchase and will be back to Frye for my next pair!

The shoes are fly!

Beautiful Boots !

Love the style and color but very difficult to get on and off. Easier without socks but who's wearing them without socks. Will be returning them.

These boots are impossible to slip over your feet, you really need to put a zipper in them.

I love my boots in Cognac! They go with everything!! I am wondering what to polish them with? Id like to shine them up as they are still great boots, but look really dingy now after a year of wearing all the time. I bought a new pair and am showing both in the picture.

I've been looking for this boot! It is classic, well constructed and fits comfortably.