Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

Love these shoes! I like the toe cleavage because I think it looks higher end (like Louboutins). I also love that the cut of the shoe does not put pressure on my bunion joint. I did wear bandaids on my heels to prevent blisters for the first couple of wears.

I was initially nervous to buy these shoes as my toes are wide and shoes don't always fit. However I was pleasantly surprised to find that these shoes fit me perfectly! They are incredibly comfortable for wearing around the office and running errands after work. They are well made with sturdy leather and a stiffer structure so they don't lose their shape. The one negative is that because the shoes are pointy, when I walk I sometimes drag my toes and scuff the shoe tip. I can't wait to get them in another color!

I love these dressy flats. They are my date shoes when I do not want to wear heels. Super stylish, but I think I should have sized down. By the end of the night, my feet were flipping out of the shoes and I finally took them off to walk to the car. I also got a blister from one, but in fairness, I wore them to an art festival and did a lot of walking- these are not made for that. I have in two colors, camel and black suede. They are super cute and stylish, though. I think they are a bit over priced, as the quality is not great, but I need a pointy toe dressy flat and these were the best I found in that style after looking a long time.

I put these shoes on for my first day of work. 30 minutes into the day, I felt my skin rubbing at the heel, and my toes were pinched. I hoped the pain would lesson throughout the day, although it did not, and even made my toes numb. unfortunately, I didn't know about the pain associated with these shoes until I had already been wearing them (Pain was nothing like this when trying them on).

I have these shoes in six colors so I obviously like them. The issue I have is they stretch in length after wearing two or three times. I am ordering another and sizing down a half size. I'm not sure this will work for me but must try.

I like these because they have the look of a d'orsay, but I don't over pronate out of them like I do sometimes with d'orsays. I also like the tiny bit of a heel.

This was the second pair of Sam Edelman Rodney flats. I absolutely adore the look and feel, but am extremely disappointed with the quality and craftsmanship. Both times, the leather disintegrated at the back of the heel, simply from driving. If you accidentally stub a toe, the front is ruined. Note to self: when the first pair fall apart in less than 3 months, don't buy a second pair :-(

Super cute, recommend sizing down due to the open style.

So beautiful but followed other reviews to order up and found that they need to be snug to stay on so will need to return and get true size 8. 8.5 fell off.

Love the pattern but I am really not into toe cleavage and they were too tight on my narrow feet. I would suggest a half size up

I liked the style in these and had a pair of 10W in black that were too big. So, I ordered these in a 9.5W and they were too narrow. Also, the back of the shoe extends half an inch behind the heel. So, when walking, the back of the shoe comes down on the ground and very quickly tears the leather at the back of the shoe, which I then had to glue back together.

These are super cute, but I'm not sure I've ever come across a pair of shoes that is more uncomfortable out of the box. I didn't even try walking around in them because they were so stiff on my foot. Frankly, I'm surprised a shoe this stiff and uncomfortable would even make it to the market.

I love this shoe style. These are second pair in black and I have two other pairs in different colors. Comfortable, all day shoe for work that works with jeans and dress pants. I do find that the leather on the front of the toe easily rips from hitting the edge of sidewalks, so I recommend taps.

The were slightly narrow, but that is due to style. I'm confident that they will loosen over time.

Beautiful, timeless, flats. You'll feel like Audrey Hepburn in them. The navy is particularly lovely. Order a half size down, so they don't slip off when you walk!

I now own these shoes in two colors and am going to get the leopard skin next. These are comfortable, practical and I've gotten compliments on them every time I've worn them. The break in period can be a tad uncomfortable, though not for long.

Runs large. I got a 7 after reading they ran big. Returned those. Then got my normal 6.5. Felt great until after a few wears. They have severely loosened up, making it hard to walk in them. Will try those heal cushions to help make them fit.

so very sorry, but i need to return these lovely shoes. i have a rather huge bunion on the top of my right foot. this shoe does not clear that bunion. but it is truly a beautiful shoe and highly recommend!

Love these Edelman’s. They fit great. I wore them thru airport right out of the box and had no blisters! Tiny bit tight in the toe box but actually stay on my foot, don’t pop off heal.

I typically wear a 6 1/2W shoe but ordered a size 6W shoe. If you order 'wide' width I recommend a 1/2 size smaller.

Beautiful! I constantly get compliments on the leopard print. They dress up a boring t-shirt / jeans combo and add a bit of edge to an otherwise boring outfit. I have wide feet and ordered a large. Fit perfectly at first, but now I’m wishing I had gotten the regular width because they stretched out quickly and are now a little loose when I walk. Still gorgeous and one of my go-tos.

I love this shoe! And it's sexy with the toe cleavage! Only problem is they're a bit too wide as most of Sam Edelman shoes usually are.

Lots of toe cleavage. I wanted these shoes to work - good tan color, but they are uncomfortable. The toe is really pointing and just covers your toes and the back does not provide much support on your ankle so it feels like work to keep the shoes on your feet. They don't seem like they will 'give' much so I'm returning them.

Too narrow for my daughter’s foot so had to return.

I have tried this style on in 3 different colors and materials and all of them fit completely different. I am a 8.5 or 9. I tried these on in the same material but different color in a 9 and they were too big, so I thought 8.5 would be great - these are way too big, but I tried a 8:5 in a different color and 8.5 was too small- the style is cute but clearly isn’t meant for my foot :(