Customer Reviews Lucky Brand Emmie

I feel like these run a little wide and I didn't care for that. They are also much darker in person and I was hoping for the color that appeared on my screen. The got returned.

I wanted to love this perfect little flat but man!! do they ever gouge into my heel/achilles. Maybe it's just my foot because I haven't found a similar pair that was truly comfortable. (Tieks included) Trying to stretch them out...we'll see!

The sizing for these flats is spot on! unfortunately, when I donned the pair, due to the padded center, I felt as if I was going to tump over...something should have been wider...the sole or the padding extended...a very strange feeling...my size is a 10W with a wide toe box and narrow heel

I love the color. It's the best out there.I've been looking for a casual flat in an animal print. They feel great and the inside has a terrific finish. Love it. The support is not poor, it's absent. None. The back of the shoe falls flat. I don't know how to explain it better. Question is, do I need $59 bathroom slippers? Still thinking, but I am very inclined to return them. Sad.

I tried so hard to buy these shoes. I generally wear a size 11M with no problem. When I ordered these in size 11 they were definitely too tight, and I'm not a believer in "shoes that will stretch" so I exchanged them for a size 12 - UNHEARD OF for me! The size 12 felt exactly like they 11. Cute as they are, they are going back.

Definitely a half size too small. Wish they had size 10.5.

I purchased this cognac color as well as the black after already owning the platinum. The cognac felt like they were two sizes too small but they were marked as the same size.

I really want to love this flat. I mean it comes in large sizes, has a cute look and comes in so many colors/prints for a resonable price. The only turn off for this shoe is that the leather doesn't hold up. I have bought about 3 pairs of these flats and they have all been thrown in the trash after about 1-3 months from getting large holes in the soles. I think if the leather were a bit more durable these shoes would be amazing.

The look of these are great, very soft leather. The bad part is the right shoe's elastic is tighter and rubs on my heel, will have to wear a band aid until I can break them in. Left feels good though. The heel feels hard and hasn't been great for walking around during a work day. I'm not sure if all these kind of flats hold the shoe on snugly, but I feel like my big toes rub the toe of the shoe when I'm walking, but when I'm sitting/standing I can push my heel back into the shoe and have plenty of room.

Nice shoes. Simple style yet exactly what I was looking for. Comfy! I managed to walk for like 10 straight hours and my feet were just okay. But the durability of this pair is just awful. They won't survive rain - glued sole started coming off. They won't survive everyday wear - the leather is scuffed on the side and back just after 1.5 months of wear. All in all, I think they are okay to wear couple of times per week but not for every day. This shoes are cheap but won't last.

I have a pair of black ones and love them. I am having a hard time with the size of these. The black ones I had to go up 1 whole size but when I bought these one size bigger than my normal they were way too big so I dropped down a half a size and they are a little too snug. I am hoping that they will stretch. Also, the color is not what I thought it would be. The picture looks more distressed (which is what I loved about it) than the actual shoe.

Very comfortable but all that extra padding makes the shoe feel kind of frumpy on my foot (in Nude specifically). Fine for fall but seems too bulky for spring or summer.

These are simple and cute but tiny. I wear an 8.5 in just about every show brand and had to squeeze my feet into these. I will try another size - maybe .5 or 1 size larger.

Runs small- I'm between and 8.5 and 9 and the 9 is right but still a bit snug. Style is beautiful- not too much toe cleavage and pretty style. Color and material look a little blah. Very light and flimsy with no support (like a slipper) but I like that. I just got them and they dig into my heel with first wearing so I put clear medical tape on my heel (or a bandaid). Cute looking.

Beautiful shoe, feels like it runs small. I ordered wide width (and in hindsight, I don't think I would have been able to put them on without it). I am usually comfortable in a 7 but in these, my toes were pushing out the edge and it felt like I was stepping off of the insole. If you order these, go larger. You will look pretty, but it will feel like walking barefoot.

I sized up 1/2 size like everyone said and they fit great! Super cute, simple, stylish flat. I got the Turkish Blue and got lots of compliments on my first day wearing them at work. Probably not a great shoe if you have to walk or stand a lot, but I walk around my building quite a bit throughout my work day and didn't have any pain or rubbing. The material is soft and comfortable from the start - no breaking in period necessary.

The leather on these is much softer than any others that I have tried (seriously, who likes all of those stiff-leather ballet flats that are available now??) but unfortunately they ran a half size or more small. I am an 8 - 9 and would need a 9 or 10, which I have never ordered. They are quite dull looking and I think the toe could use a little shape stylistically. Too bad.

I ordered a size 11 (which is my true size) they were comfortable at first but as I wore them during the day it felt like my feet wanted to explode out of them. Of course I already threw out the the box and receipt so I can't return them. Basically they run a little small.

I bought these shoes off the reviews. They are okay if you are at work and sitting for periods of time. Mine are very uncomfortable for walking at the mall or long periods of time. They are very tight through the middle part of your foot and do not have support. I would not purchase them again.

They look like I expected, but were small. I normally wear a 9, ordered a 9.5 and they were still really snug and uncomfortable on my foot. I might try again with a size 10 and see if that ends up better.

These shoes are so comfortable. I pulled them out of the box and was able to wear them all day. There was no break in time. I have had the 2 weeks and there is already a hole on the inside of the shoe which is a bummer since they were not inexpensive. Overall I love the comfort of the shoe and the style but I am not sure how long they will last. I did go up a half size from some other reviews I read and they are a perfect fit.

I bought 2 pairs of the Emmie in 2015. Fast forward to 2015, they have gotten smaller and the quality of the leather has decreased. I wear a size 12. So this time I noticed that they were available in size 12w. But they were smaller than the original 12's that I bought in 2013. I love these flats, but the sizing isn't consistent from year to year.

A lovely little shoe - very elegant and graceful, and beautifully constructed - but too delicate-looking for my short, wide feet and thick ankles! A bit youthful for me too, perhaps (I'm 57). It just didn't work on me with any part of my wardrobe at all. The leather was luscious, though, the insole was nicely padded, and the sole was very grippy/non-slip; however, the upper edge of the heel dug into my heel, so I would have needed heel pads if keeping.

Really cute, but they hurt! The back of the right shoe digs into my heel. I'm normally an 8-1/2 or 9, I ordered a 9 and still had that problem. I tried to wear around for a few minutes but the problem only seemed to get worse. Unfortunately, I will be returning. The pattern looks great though, and looks like it would hide dirt well.

I have now tried on 3 pairs of these shoes and although all of them were a size 9 1/2 they all fit differently. The navy pair fit perfectly, the black pair were very tight, and the green pair the left shoe was almost 1/2 an inch bigger than the right shoe. As long as you don't mind returns when they get it right it's a very comfortable shoe.