Customer Reviews Earth Shelly

I wanted to love these shoes, but the fit was just awkward for my foot. I am usually a true medium width, but these felt wide and sloppy.

These shoes run wide and long, much longer and wider than some other Earth styles. I wear an 11W and the 11W in this shoe was a half size too big (at least) and was sloppy on my foot. They are also not as cute in person, on the foot the style looks a frumpy. They are soft and flexible though, and probably would be comfortable for standing.

Stylish, but makes "farty" sounds while walking. I've had Earth Brand shoes in the past, and expected more. Broke them in walking around room, but the problem has not diminished.

Very cute but too loose on me toward the front of the shoe, but not enough to go down a size. Wish they fit. Too cute

Cute, good arch support but felt like a size 9 instead of 8.5 Too long.

Not the same shoe. I ordered these in the pearlized color because I loved these shoes last year. Apparently I ordered a medium width last year as there must not have been my usual wide option. When these arrived at least I had learned my lesson and tried them on. Not only were they too wide (my fault for not looking at last year's shoes) but they were too long and the insole was much harder than the one in last year's models. If you look at the colors they had last year as opposed to the new colors, you can see the difference in the insoles. The older ones had very comfortable insoles. The new colors do not, so I'm returning these shoes without changing widths because they are not nearly as comfortable.

Top kinda stiff and cut in to my big toes upon flexing my feet. A little clunky looking.

I ordered a second pair of this shoe as they are very comfortable. Unfortunately, they had been worn (inside) but enough to show not to mention the lack of care in returning the product in its original condition. So, I am returning just hope that in the future products are more carefully checked before shipping out again!

I didn't like the shoe as much in person as I liked it online. Depending on the shoe I am a medium or wide width. This one I definitely needed something wider. I could get my foot in, but it didn't look good. Also I think the shoe is a 1/2 size too long.

Very cute shoe and seemed comfy. Just a little loose and not quite enough arch support for my planters fasciitis. I reluctantly sent them back. Loved them with capris and leggings. Would be a very good transitional shoe for fall

Nice shoe, but the top part cuts into my foot and is uncomfortable. If it had been cut just a little lower, it would have been better. Too bad, because I wanted to like them.

Sadly, these are going back. Based on other reviews stating it runs wide, I took a chance on a B width shoe. If a shoe is a B, I can't wear a style like this where there's leather across the base of my toes where my foot has a bunion. These were no exception. Could barely get my foot in them. Too bad they don't come in a wide width, because the color is great, and they look really comfy.

Very cute and comfy but these are going back. To toe box was wide and my foot slipped around, I was worried the little elastic straps would not last.

So disappointed. I wanted to love these, and they are so comfortable, but the boxy cut and the overly long toe bed are really not attractive. And the shoe fit is off. Arch support was a half inch back.

Beautiful looking sandal, cushioned footbed. Sadly, very wide....had to return. Size 8.5medium

I listened to other customers who said order a half size down. Which I did, and the fit was good. But the back of the shoe is so wide, it slipped up and down as I walked. I had to send them back. Too bad, because they were really cute and comfortable.

This order contained 2 Earth styles. Both seemed a full size larger and I returned them. As far as style and quality, I liked them.

I was a little unsure about the style, but they looked really comfortable and had good reviews. But they were just as dowdy as I thought they'd be when they arrived, so I returned them. They just aren't that cute sadly.

Purchased these based on previous reviews. They are not true to size. Should have bought a size smaller

The front half of the shoe was beyond wide -- I wear a wide shoe, but this one had enough room that I could have fit my hand between the top of the toe area and my actual toes. Too bad, since they're otherwise nice shoes.

It was too long in the back. My foot slid up and down. Maybe that’s a width issue, I don’t know. I ordered another Earth brand and the fit was the same. Sad, because I liked the way they both fit otherwise. Wide enough for my forefoot, and felt very comfortable to stand on. In fact, when I stood up after trying them on, the soles of my feet sighed in relief.

I loved these shoes . I tried 2 different pairs . You can hear them pop and squish in the arch when you walk. One pair on one foot the other pair on both. I wanted to keep them. They are very comfortable, pretty and perfect for my trip to Israel. I am sending them back because I can't have people hearing me walk. It must be something in the construction of the shoe. :(

So disappointed i n theses shoes. I wear an 8.5 wide, and these were more like a 11. The width was okay, but they were about two inches longer than my toes. The color was right and material felt good, but the size was just way out of control. Sending them back.

Not the shoe pictured. Earth has changed their foot bed from the formerly soft, comfortable, supportive style (as pictured) to one that is hard and non-cushioned, with little arch support. Time to find a different brand.

I really wanted to like these shoes. I usually wear an 8.5 wide in Earth shoes. The 8.5W was huge. I tried an 8 wide and an 8 medium. Still too big.