Customer Reviews Earth Shelly

Cute shoe but very long. I usually get an 8.5 in earthies because they tend to run short. This one I will need to go down a full size.

I wear a size 5 and I have wide feet. It's pretty difficult to find cute comfortable shoes. I wanted something casual to wear with jeans, shorts, etc. These shoes worked out perfectly for all of the above. I love the softness of the leather and the footbed is very comfortable. I walked around in them all day with no problem. The reason for a 4 rating is I have a high instep and the shoes did not come in Wide. I had to have them stretched in order for them to slide in comfortably as the top of the shoe comes up high on the foot. Overall, worth it as they are light, cute and well-made.

These are an incredibly comfortable shoe. I ordered them because I have the Earth Bootie with the same perforated print, and even the small heel ends up being too much for me. Unfortunately, something happens when this is turned into a flat and I feel like it looks too much like an orthopedic/old lady shoe. Too bad because I know I could endlessly walk in these - I really need something to replace my years old Earth gladiator sandal!

Did not work for me because I have a hogh arch. After an hour of wearing the elastic was digging in so much I had to take the shoes off.

These shoes looked oddly masculine to me once I tried them on. They give the appearance of a loafer. The toe opening rubs on the side of my big toe and my heel slips out of the back. So sad to say I will have to return them.

Loved this shoe, felt good as soon as I slipped it on. After walking around in the house for a while the top of my foot was irritated by the top of the shoe as well as the top of my big toe. Unfortunately they are going back. I love zappos!

Super cute and seemed really comfortable. The dusty blue is really nice, and would go with practically anything. I was really disappointed to have to return these, but unfortunately my heels kept slipping out of them.

Cute! Very comfy design, but very little arch support. I ordered my usual 6.5 and they fit perfectly. I wanted them for all day wear, but since I need more arch support so I have to send them back...so sad.

It was loose overall and since it was a nice suede, stretching was anticipated. It flopped when I walked like a flip flop on the left foot. I wished it fit better because I like a sandal that doesn't have a narrow strap across the bunion area. I think a 9 would have been too small and this 9.5 didn't fit well. I returned these.

They are so cute but run short and narrow.

These shoes are really cute and comfortable, but I ordered the place in buck, and within half and hour my feet were black from the dye. and I returned them. I have reordered in taupe hoping that I will not have the same issue as the black pair.

These sandals a really cute and comfortable, but unfortunately as has been noted in other reviews, after wearing these for less than ten minutes my feet were black from the dye. For this reason I am returning these :-(

Why do companies add so much to width of shoe when a person goes up in size??

Love the style but after only 2 wearings the shoe was all stretched out. very floppy on my foot. Had to return.

I am still undecided about this shoe. It fills the need I have and is ok comfort wise. I bought the black because that is the color I needed but the nubuck leather does leave some stain on your feet and shows dust and dog fur easily. I paid the sale price of $69 for them but even that seem high. I take a 10 and 1/2 narrow generally, these fit in a 10M.

I ordered the light blue in D width. Very comfortable. Thought I could wear a C, but it's too tight. D's weren't available in Black.

These are cute but they were a little wide in the heel and my foot shifted too much. Not great as far as support.

I am always a 10D, if not 10 1/2 or even 11, and these shoes were swimming on my feet. going to re-order in 9 m and see how that goes.

I wish these had worked out. The shoe itself was so pretty. The length was perfect, but there was far too much room for my low volume feet to feel secure in. It was much too loose overall.

Hmmm... I wanted to like these but just couldn't. I've got a wide foot and while they fit, they just looked like I was wearing perforated boxes on my feet. Not a flattering look! Suede material is soft and supple, I can say that much for them.

tried two different sizes, could not get either to work. Very cute!

Love the look of this shoe and was looking for a comfy, supportive and cute vacation walking shoe. But ultimately the fit didn't work for me. Ordered an 11 (I'm a 10.5 standard) and these fit nice in length with a splash of room so I'd say true to size. At my size, they run a little wide. I would have liked a more formed fit over the top of my foot. The footbed is VERY comfortable so I would have considered keeping them had this not happened: I put them on and took 2 steps the and open toe edge dug hard into the top of each big toe on each step. Said NOPE and put them back in the box. I would have had an instant blister. Perhaps just my problem based on the loose fit. Might work better for others!

These shoes run very big. I was very disappointed in the style when they came. They looked much cuter on the website. There is arch support, which is unusual in a flat, and the leather is very soft.

These shoes make "farty" sounds often while walking. They're cute, but difficult to get used to the sounds. Thought that after breaking them in on vacation the sound would stop, but no. I've had Earth Shoes in the past without this issue, but I'm now afraid to try other styles. Tried babypowder, to no avail.

Cute but huge