Customer Reviews Earth Shelly

I wanted this taupe color in a comfy low sandal and this fit the bill. They are really comfy and look with anything, from dresses to shorts. I love them. I am generally a size 10, sometimes a 9.5 especially in sandals. I liked the 9.5 better in this sandal, but I HATE toes that spill over the front or the back of a sandal, and the 9.5 did neither. I've had people say they love them and others think meh. But I like them a lot.

I ordered these in a neutral Taupe color size 10. Looking for a comfortable walking sandal that has a feminine look for my foot. The size 10, which is my usual shoe size, was extremely long/wide. I reordered it in size 9 and 9.5 to see which will fit. The style is cute and very comfortable.

Very comfortable footbed, great fit. The open toe is uncomfortable for me so I am returning. If it were closed they definintely would stay in my closet.

I love my Earth/Earthies shoes, but these are lacking the needed arch support that my other Earth/Earthies shoes have. (Still more arch support/cushion than your hard flat, but not enough for me. ) I have a somewhat narrow foot and the part of this shoe that goes over your foot was a little loose for my foot.

Love these shoes but it is true they stain your feet black.. It doesn't show until you take the shoes off so I can put up with it. Just an excuse to use my foot bath and relax ?? the size eight is perfect and the width is a little on the narrow side of medium so perfect for me. Really cute on.

I first ordered these shoes in the beige color. Liked them so well I ordered them in black too. I have received several compliments on the style which I was somewhat leery about in the beginning since I usually were slides or flip flops. They are comfortable and have great support without being too hard. I normally were a B width in most shoes but ordered the wide with this style after trying the first pair in my normal size. I'm personally glad I did. I think it is because of where the side bands hit on my foot. It does not feel quite so tight. This might not be the case for everyone so I suggest starting with your normal size and see what you think.

I really wanted to be able to keep these, they're so comfy right out of the box. The suede is super soft and they hide my bunions and hammertoes really well. However, for some reason, whenever I took a step, the arch part of the shoe would kind of suction cup itself to my foot and then it would make an embarassing noise with each step. Not something I want to be doing at work haha. So, unfortunately they have to be returned.

I love these! This is my second pair as I returned the first pair because these run wide and big. I usually order a 7 wide or double wide and returned these for a 6.5 D. These are the perfect fit! Thought maybe the elastic on the sides might bother me, but I don't even feel it! They do have an arch and I have a very flat foot so I can really feel it. It's a nice quality shoe and the nubuck is beautiful. Before purchasing look at the back of the shoe which has a little cut out that makes it look extra special. Think I may order a second pair!

I like my other Earth sandals and this one would have likely worked well but the sizing was too large. Nice color that would go with most any summer outfits. I did think I would be prefer something more "strappy" style for dresses so I returned without asking for a size down that would have likely fit well.

I have wide feet and the shoe was too wide. Also slips in the heel. I was hoping for a good fit. Cute shoe but will have to go back.

They look cute, but the arch support isn’t great. Also, the part of the shoe that touches the ground is more narrow than the sole of the shoe, so they felt a little “tippy”. I’m just looking for a flat sandal. I returned them.

Cute shoe but it hurt my toes!!!

I had so hoped that these would have worked. They run long so I reordered an 8 1/2 wide...however the heel slips. Dang... Good looking & comfy shoe.

I really wanted to love these shoes. I was trying to find some cute summery shoes that weren’t flip flops. Love these but the 8W were too small and 8.5W too big. The width was good on both but length was not right. Thank goodness for Zappo’s for free shipping and returns. It’s so hard to find wide width shoes for ladies in stores especially cute ones. I’d recommend trying these on for size first. Really cute shoes though...and comfy.

This shoe is very cute, but was wider than expected. It's my first Earth shoe, so maybe this brand is a bit wider than normal. I usually wear a 6M and the shoe fit lengthwise. The back strap isn't adjustable. The back of the shoe didn't hug my heel. It sagged so it felt loose on my foot. My foot is not narrow - I always fit mediums, but sadly I had to return this one. I'm giving a 3 for comfort mainly because my foot was moving around too much in the shoe. There's a little arch support and the footbed has some cushion

Really cute...felt half size longer than expected.

Let's open with this: I have a lot of back and knee problems so it's really hard for me to find the right shoe. I really liked the look of this shoe in the box and from the side but when I tried it on and looked in the mirror, they looked a little too much like a mesh slipper from a distance. Perhaps something you'd see someone in prison wear to the shower - not sure, I've never been. I have a narrow foot and they felt too wide. I also have really high arches and the support was there but not enough of it. Sadly, I will have to return them.

Cute shoe, but too lose in the heel for me. Also, would prefer footbed to be same color as suede on the shoe. Feel great on and have good arch support.

I liked the style

Really comfortable and good looking shoe.

I like these shoes! I think they will go with most clothes in my summer wardrobe. A need for arch support and a knee injury has me searching for flats and these are great. Could be a tad bit narrower for looks, but they feel great! but did have to return my usual size 9.5 for a 9 but that is often the case with me, just never know which is why I Love Zappos!

I wanted to love these shoes. My usual 7 wide was much too big, the 6.5 wide felt good except that the back of the shoe came up so high that is rubbed .

Love the shoes . Fit is great. However,I feel like I'm standing in a hole falling backwards.They are too low

This is a very cute shoe that I was hoping would work well for me. I ordered my normal size 8M and they were too big. I'm having to return them and am debating about ordering the 7 1/2M. They looked nice on and seemed like they would be comfortable if they fit. My heel was sliding out of them.

The shoes are stunning and practical. I have had five foot surgeries and was astounded at the excellent story upport this sandal provides. However for whatever reason, the band across the toes of both the left and right rubbed my big toe. I'm crushed, because I would have bought in multiple colors. I tried fixing the rub by wearing in the house with a band aid on each big toe, but still was too uncomfortable to justify keeping. Very unfortunate, as it's a classic sandal and would be perfect for casual or dress up. Heartbroken that it has to be returned.