Customer Reviews Naturalizer Samantha

I had to return these shoes. I have a problem with bunions and this style hurt a lot.

The toe box was too shallow, had to send back. Pretty shoe otherwise.

When I tried them on at home and walked around they were great but when I got out onto actual walking surfaces they hurt and my right shoe kept flapping like the fit was too big. The look if the shoes and materisl is beautiful but the wear is very uncomfortable and since I wore them out on surfaces I will be unable to return them. I am very disappointed. I am writing this review on my phone and I am unable to scroll up to check my spelling so I apologize if any errors.

Very cheap looking.

One of the reasons I like Naturalizer is that they have pads under the ball of the foot. In this shoe, the padded part was more under my toes and less under the balls of my foot. It also pinched my feet when I walked. It just wasn’t a good fit for my feet. Maybe if I had narrower feet they’d fit better.

Right out of the box, felt as if my feet would slip out. I ordered my usual size 8W.

Love the style. I bought the black satin and it's gorgeous. Then I put them on.... The soles are nice like most Naturalizer and they look great. What did them in though was that with each step the top of the shoe cut into the top of my foot. They are being returned.

I have ordered this shoe in so many sizes... I wish I could figure out which one is supposed to fit because I truly love the style. I'm usually a 10.5, regular width. Here are the sizes of this shoe that don't fit me: 10.5 Regular (too long). 10 Regular (Too tight, but if looser would be too long). 9.5 Wide (Too tight, still!). I don't understand the sizing of this shoe. I'm perplexed. For the sizing questions, I would like to be able to reply ("all of the above")

Uncomfortable, top of shoe cut into my foot. Couldn't leave them on longer than five minutes.

This shoe cuts across the widest part of my foot, making it appear wide. My shoe width is N. Not only is it unflattering, the design is painful on my bunions

This shoe is a great color nude against bare skin. The foot bed was cushioned so it felt somewhat supportive but the toe box comes up too high and when you walk, it cuts into the top of your foot. Plus the shape was more pointy in person than it looked online.

I wear an 8N in every other Naturalizer I have, but this one was very short and pinched my toes. A half size larger would have been too long and pointy in this style. I am only 5’ 3”, so anything that lengthens my weirdly long and narrow foot is not good! I loved the style and high quality leather, but sadly, it was returned. Thank goodness for Zappos amazing return policy!!

These shoes shredded my heels raw even with added heel pads. Disappointed. I ordered an 8 which is my normal size. I could not size down or up, so maybe I just need to break them in more? Wish I could return.

I bought these shoes for an event in DC/ I live in CA. I tried them on prior to leaving my home, and they felt fine. We were going to walk a couple of blocks to our meeting, and I couldn't walk a step without the shoe falling off - I couldn't believe it! I changed my shoes and left them in my room when I checked out because they weren't even worth taking extra space in my luggage. Total fail!

I will try this again BUT i ordered a 7.5 and received a 8.

These were so pretty, but way too tight and narrow! I usually wear an 8.5 W or WW, and the wide was skintight and uncomfortable to walk in. I wish they were available in a WW; I'd buy them in a heartbeat.

Super cute but the W were not even close to wide enough to get my foot into. Had to go back.

The middle of the shoe opening cuts into the foot. I wear a nine narrow it was too long. Good looking shoe,bad fit.

These shoes felt like they would fit perfectly, be very comfortable, and they looked beautiful on my foot, but the way they are styled -cut all the way down at the instep- made it obvious that I would walk completely out of them. My foot was sliding so far over (inward) it nearly touched the floor. It could be because I have a high arch, but whatever the reason I had to send them back.

I ordered a size smaller and when I put them on they felt OK. I packed them for a work event. They are horrible within 30 minutes they were too big slipping off my feet rubbing my heels have blisters leg cramps etc. ruined my day. I missed a concert because I was having such leg cramps. I don’t have like cramps on a regular basis ! Thinking they fit I threw away the box. So I can’t return them! Be super careful if you have narrow feet. These don’t work!

Super disappointed with these. I ordered an 8.5 and a 9 to determine the best size. The 8.5 was too small so I opted for the size 9. The first day I wore them they stretched out and were too big. They were super uncomfortable and hard to keep on my foot. Despite the pain and annoyance I wore them maybe 4 more times to work only to discover that the soles are separating. I’m not hard on shoes at all and even if I were, shoes should not be falling apart after 5 wears! I’ll be throwing them away. Do not recommend.