Customer Reviews Naturalizer Samantha

These felt true to size and are really cute. Unfortunately, they cut across the widest part of my foot and I can feel them digging in when I walk so they have to go back.

These were slightly too long for me. Not a even a half size, but enough for my heel to slip. The width was ok (I have wide feet) but they were very stiff - no flexibility and the leather was hard. I knew it would be a painful break in. They are absolutely gorgeous though and just what I wanted, the fit just didn’t work for me.

Beware! I love the look, style and material workmanship of these shoes and was so excited to wear them. I tried them on out of the box and walked through the house and they felt comfortable so I decided to keep them. I put them on for a day of wear during my work day. By the time I walked from the car, across the parking lot and up the stairs to a meeting, they were completely flopping off my feet!!! OMG! It was completely embarrassing. I had to go to the restroom and stuff the toes of the shoes with tissue to reduce the space in the shoes so I could get back to the car and go home. One wear and I’m done. $89 down the drain. Ugh. Can’t return them since they’re worn. So disappointed.

I was pretty disappointed. Naturalizer is known for their comfortable shoes so I was willing to spend a little more. They aren’t comfortable. They’re very stiff and have very little cushioning. I can tell that I am going to get blisters. I bought them to wear to work, but standing on my feet for 12 hours in these shoes is not an option. They are very cute, but not worth the high price tag.

Really cute shoe, but runs a little small.

After trying both a 9.5 Medium width (my normal size) and a wide, my bunyons told me to go with the wide. It gave them just a tad bit more room so that by the end of the day, they weren't screaming at me, I've gotten loads of compliments on these classics, and use them in place of heels if at all possible. Wore them out of the box, to an evening wedding; danced without even taking them off, and wore them to work (teacher) 5 days later all day, with very little issue. My only complaint after those two wearings is that the soles look like they may be the first to go ~ I'm super sad about this because they are the most comfy pointy shoes I've found. Hoping I'm wrong. For reference, the taupe is a little less camel color than in the online picture...lighter than they appear.

these were described as taupe leather. They were a metallic gold.

Not what I was hoping for, unfortunately. Not as comfortable as I expect from this brand.

So the shoe is cute in theory, but it makes your feet look a little big, and if you have narrow feet, this is probably not the shoe for you. I probably needed a half size smaller so maybe this shoe runs a half size too big.

The caramel is smaller than the black suede, which I love. It rubs the tops of my feet and heels. But, going a size up would be too big. Also, it seems that it would form a crease on the top where you bend your feet, which my black suede pair has not done.

This is such a great looking shoe but since I have a very narrow heel, the back of the shoe kept sliding off. I hate to return it, but must.

Just OK

Love the satin black finish, but with each step, the edge of the toe box dug into the top of my foot. Returning...

I loved the style so much and I really wanted these to work. They fit length-wise, but they felt like they were cutting into the wide part of my foot, and they were uncomfortably hitting into the inside of my heel. Had to return both pairs I ordered.

I ordered a wide and they were way too narrow, they didn't even look wide. This was a big disappointment, they look like they'd be a nice pair of shoes.

This is a darling shoe in a unique style. However, it is laughable that this shoe is labeled as wide. Even tried on first thing in the morning and couldn't even get my foot in it. Oh well.

I wear Naturalizer Brand most of the time. These shoes were tight for me. I am a size 10 and have a foot on the narrow side. I was disappointed and returning. Continuing to search for a show for my daughters wedding.

After reading the reviews I decided to try these just around the house first. Too tight around the toes, after five minutes I had to take them off. I’m a 9B and don’t have wide feet. Disappointed, I really like this style.

RUN VERY WIDE NICE LOOKING SHOE BUT DEFINITELY NOT A NARROW

Overall pretty unimpressed with this shoe. It wasn’t as elegant as I’d hoped; the design felt awkward and unflattering. I ended up returning them in favor of the BCBGeneration Millie flat and am very pleased with my choice!

These run big and loose. The leather is not soft and rich...feels kind of cheap and plastic like

Shoe kept slipping off of heel, so it runs large. I thought the style was decent but I didn’t care for how much of the front of my foot was covered.

I truly wanted to like these shoes, because the color and styling are awesome. However, the edge of toe section is WAY TOO TIGHT for a M width shoe. Sadly will return them.

I loved the look of this shoe, but it wasn't wide enough for me. The toe box of the shoe crosses right over the widest part of my foot. There is a tiny bit of elastic to help that line stretch over your foot, but it was just much too narrow. I'm sure it would work well for someone who has feet only barely wider than standard width. The heel will take time to break in -- beware. I only tried these shoes on for a few minutes and it was already rubbing the back of my heel raw.