Customer Reviews Naturalizer Samantha

A bit longer than expected and could hardly be considered narrow, even though it's a 9N. Guess I'll just have to spend more money on pads so that they'll fit correctly, even though these narrows were supposed to actually be narrow.

Very stylish and love the color, however, not comfortable.

These slipped off my foot easily and I returned them. They look cute though and narrower than my feet like, although my feet are pretty wide.

The length was fine but this did not feel narrow at ALL in the toe box. My heel didn't slip out so that's good but it was very roomy in the toe box. Almost like someone had worn it and stretched it out. It was weird. But I kept them because I absolutely had to have shoes for a function.

They fit but had absolutely no arch support. So I returned them. They were nice looking, seemed well made for the price but because of the lack of support ( which I should’ve known by the style) they had to go back. They were dressy.

I love the look of this shoe but it is not one that you can put on and wear all day without issues. I am a true 9 1/2. This feels like it is a 9 3/4 because the heels won't stay on my feet. I did buy the pads that go in the back of the shoe and that helped. The shoe box rubs/cuts the top of my foot. I had to put on a band-aid within about 15 minutes of wearing them. I imagine that they may stretch out a bit and I will keep them but you're not going to find comfort or support with this shoe. It's disappointing considering it is a Naturalizer and it is over $100 when not on sale.

I loved the taupe color and style, but unfortunately found these to run small and very narrow (I was already at a 11W, and so sadly there is not a larger size available).

I really wanted to like these shoes but they are quite long in person. They had a lot of extra shoe to accommodate the point without squishing the toes. Returned.

I really wanted to keep these. I love the style and the soft yellow was perfect. However the edge of the shoe was right on my bunion. The width looked good and they seem to run a bit long. So I figured a half size smaller should get my foot past that opening point but those were much much narrower even though the width was ordered the same. Sadly I returned both pairs. Comfortable foot bed but not much support if your arch is high.

Not as stylish as I’d hoped for.

I felt like my foot would have absolutely no support. Cute but had to go back.

What can I say? The style was just not right for me. The fit was spot on. The idea was there, but something about the pointed toe threw me off. Not my personal choice, but a lovely shoe for someone I am sure.

Unfortunately, the first day I wore these shoes out, my feet kept slipping out of the shoes, so much so that I had to stop and put my foot back in. They seemed a bit too long after wearing them. I can't return them since I wore them for a few hours, but I definitely would send back if I could.

These flats were comfortable, but they are quite plain. I sent them back, still searching for a cute, comfortable pair of black flats!!

These fit nicely and were comfortable but I didn’t like the style or the color. Cookie dough is a metallic beige with a lot of pink undertones.

These shoes are very cute in person but the suede toe seems like it would get scuffed fairly easily. My usual shoe size is a 9.5, so I tried on a 10, 9.5 and 9. The 9 fit the best but my heal still slipped out a bit as I walked around. Also this shoe has zero arch support- where the arch of the foot sits there’s actually no shoe there, it’s cut away. There is padding where the ball of the foot goes, but it seems to be placed too far forward so that it sits before the ball of the foot, not underneath. I appreciate the effort to make a cute and comfortable shoe, but this one’s not for me.

I normally wear an 8 1/2 and this was way to small. I'd guess I'd need a full size bigger.

I have this shoe in black and in silver, 6.5 wide. This taupe leather pair is a little narrower across the top than the other ones I have. When I put the shoe on, the leather crumples and creases easily and it looks bad. The color and style is perfect. Still though, they’re getting returned.

I normally wear a 9.5N and that is what I ordered. Will return because I have very flat feet and there is no arch support and no good way to add one. Style is better than average for a narrow shoe. Wish it had a tad more heal- better for your foot. The width was good - and I think it would actually stay on my very narrow heal.

I like the look of this shoe but when I put it on the leather started to fold in an unappealing way. Unfortunately I have bunions and this happens in certain styles for me. I kept them because they are comfortable and I need brown shoes, and they are dressy enough for some work outfits.

This was cute and fit well, but walking around the house in them felt...odd. I do over pronate and this shoe made my foot roll more noticeable, I think. I never encountered a shoe like this so I had to return it.

Made my foot look really wide. Cut right across my bunion

Ordered size 9 it was a true fit, very comfy and stylish however if you have bunions the opening was right there and did not look good. I’d suggest for normal feet only otherwise your bunion will be popping out.

Cute shoe. Perfect for "elevated casual". Problem was - they wouldn't stay on my feet. More than 2 steps and they are flapping worse than flip flops. Don't think I can go a half size smaller - I think my toes will be scrunched - but I might try. They are pretty darn cute.