Customer Reviews Naturalizer Samantha

These are adorable, but ultimately I did not feel they'd win out over my comfortable Rothy's that I wear to the office most days. This is a very nicely made and stylish shoe but a bit stiff.

Just walking around the house these started pinching a bit at the toe box. I need a pair of dress blacks that I can wear all the time so I am returning these.

Love the style! Very trendy and great looking. I am so sad that the fit did not suit my foot. The edge on the inside of ankle and at big toe joint dug in. Had to return them.

These are very cute and stylish shoes. I love that they have a super low heel. Would definitely recommend them to others.

Beautiful quality just didn't fit my foot well.

I am a teacher and bought these for school. They took a few days to break in but now they are cute, comfortable, and offer a little more support than many other flats.

Nice flexible, soft shoe. The top doesn't completely cover my bunion but doesn't seem to pinch the joint or hurt. I haven't worn them for a full day yet though. I normally wear a 7.5W but had to return the first pair because they were about an inch too long. The 7W fits fine. My heel still slips a little, but I think that is due to my narrow heels and not because the shoe is too big.

I really like the blue and orange plaid pattern. Very pretty!

Cute but was an inch too long. Same size I wear in Naturalizer.

these are an awesome flat with a cute cut out detail! The downfall... they stretch out within a few months. I expected to have them for a full year before they felt too big.

I love these shoes which look good in pants, dresses or skirts. They are very comfortable for me to walk in, despite the lack of arch support. This really surprised me. My only complaint is that the heel is a little wide on a narrow foot. They also run long, and came off my feet when I walked. I sent my regular size back and ordered a half size down which fixed this problem for me.

I had high hopes, but the shoe was completely too small.

This shoe is adorable and a perfect summer work shoe so I can’t rate it badly. However being Naturalizer I thought there would be some arch support but there is just nothing. I really wanted to keep them but knew I’d be in pain.

This show is so cute, but runs small. I am normally 6.5 in every brand, but these are extremely tight. Sad I have to return them as they look very nice.

My shoe size is 8.5 for most brands and I ordered the 8.5M for this shoe. I have normal width feet. The toe box fits perfectly width-wise and doesn't squeeze my toes together. It's also long enough that my toes don't jam against the front of the shoe as I walk, either. The disappointing part is how loose the heel became after wearing these shoes inside for a couple of hours. I can tell that the toe box would be too small if I ordered down a size, so my only option is to buy heel inserts. The footbed is nicely padded and overall it's a comfortable shoe.

Super cute! I have a friend who recommended them and loves them. I got the satin, not the leather (she has the leather), so maybe it made a difference. They just hit my foot at the wrong place and cut into it - I couldn't walk in them.

Really cute but I have a chubby foot and doesn’t look good on my foot.

I have narrow feet and can never wear flats because they flop off my feet. I was hoping the 10N in this style would help me change that, but no, Naturalizer narrows seem to be too wide for me.

The multi brocade is a BEAUTIFUL, comfortable, well fitting shoe! However, ladies with bunions will be terribly disappointed because the vamp line actually showcases the exposed bunion. So hard to find a d’orsay style that covers the bunion. ?? sigh...

I will put this in all my reviews from now on: To start off I have bad feet. Super high arches and have had hammertoes and I have the beginning of bunions. I also have Peripheral neuropathy. Long story short: my feet are always in pain from the minute I wake up until I go to sleep. I ordered this shoe in 7.5 M. I bought the black leather one. I love the d'Orsay style and was happy Naturalizer made a flat in that style. It fits true to size, I don't have any pain in them. There is not arch support but these are not for every day wear and not for hours upon hours either so that is ok with me. It's a d'Orsay style so there won't be much arch support, especially the support I usually need. But for special occasions and not a lot of walking, which is why I purchased this shoe, I think it fits the bill. It's a nice dressy flat for when you can't be in heels. I wish they made it in an all leather and not the suede part too. I feel that makes it so I can only wear this shoe in the cooler weather. I know they make it in satin but I don't want a satin shoe.

Very cute. Wanted to love them and keep them. Style was great. However, I could just tell these would rub part of my feet, so I would never wear them. Had to begrudgingly return.