Customer Reviews Naturalizer Samantha

Tried really hard to love this shoe - it's the perfect style for what I was looking for. However, after first wear to work, it seemed that the shoe must be too big. My foot kept slipping pretty far forward into the front, which exacerbated the main deal-breaker: this shoe tears up the back of my heels. I have tried the squishy heel inserts, I have tried bandaids, I have tried both together - it's a no go. Pros: wide enough for my wider-than-average foot; fairly cushioned for a flat; excellent style Cons: feet slide forward, rubs heels to raw and beyond

These didn't fit me well. I ordered them in a wide width, but even then the top of the shoe hit my foot at the widest part making it uncomfortable and ugly on me.

Cute, stylish, but I filtered for arch support and there is nothing supporting anything in this shoe. Disappointed.

Too flat (no support) and toe box is too narrow (would cut into my

These are beautiful shoes, unfortunately they were completely unwearable for me. I wear some regular width, some wide width shoes. My feet are not extremely wide. I ordered these in a wide width and could not even get the shoe on past my toes. The wide width version of this shoe is narrower than the regular width of other shoes I ordered at the same time from brands like Clarks. If they were wide enough to get on, I think I still would have had issues with how stiff the leather is, the sharp edges, and the complete lack of arch support or padding on the sole. Not in any way a comfort shoe unless you have particularly flat, narrow feet.

The shoes are cute but won't stay on my feet- I am forever stepping out of them and it makes walking impossible. Too late to return, so they are going in the trash.

Absolutely loved the look of these shoes. Very cute. The first pair I bought were too big and I could not keep them on my feet, I put pads in them which helps. I had wore them so I had to keep them, but I also bought another pair 1/2 size smaller I wore them twice. The second time I did more walking in them and the most annoying thing happened... they are squeaky. It is so annoying that I cannot wear them. So now I am stuck with 2 pair of the same shoes and neither work.

This shoe is cut at an odd angle across the instep, and is too narrow. Most Naturalizer shoes (medium width) fit me perfectly.

Tiny, tiny little shoes. No support and very uncomfortable. The gap in the middle dug into my foot uncomfortable. I don’t recommend.

These have a cute style but they are two shades lighter brown than what is shown in the picture. I ordered a 9, my normal size, and they were too big. I returned.

No way some one with a bunion could wear these - hits right on the bone.

I really wanted to love these... they were super stiff and uncomfortable ?

Way too narrow. Ordered a wide and it was really tight across the front/top.

I found these shoes to be quite narrow and they cut into the top and side of my foot (I don’t have overly wide feet). I also did not like how long the pointed toe was. The shoes were both unattractive and uncomfortable.

These shoes were extremely comfortable and I wore them all day right out of the box. Unfortunately, the pointy toe scuffs very easily and started peeling after only one day. So bummed because I loved the fit and style, but I just wasted money on shoes that I could only really wear once.

Absolutely not a wide shoe. A waste of my time to order and return. Really love the style though. It's a shame!

I got the red ones. They fit fine but when I had them on I looked like a cross between Buddy the elf and one of the munchkins from Oz. I think they would probably look very nice on someone tall and willowy but sadly, that is not me.

I love the style of these shoes and they go with everything. However, they've stretched out to the point that I can't walk in them anymore because they slip right off my feet. I am between a 9.5 and a 10 usually. I purchased a 9.5 and they were snug in the beginning, but they stretched out very quickly. Additionally, the heels of each shoe are completely worn out and falling apart. I am bummed because shoes like these ones are difficult to find, but they are simply not worth the money.