Customer Reviews Naturalizer Whitney

My heel slipped out of these I’m going to try another style loved the shoes the heel is perfect cute shoe

They look cute on Zappos models. Naturalizer shoes NEVER work for me. They are always inconsistent from one style to another in this brand. Great styles, however this brand does not work for me.

This shoe runs long. It was hard to tell if it felt true to width because it was so long my foot slipped out. The style seems like it would be cute with slacks.

I like a bigger heel, but this really looked clunky and not cute. My husband, who usually doesn't care about shoes at all, even thought they were pretty ugly.

I normally wear a 9.5 narrow but I tried all the way down to 8.5 narrow which actually did fit in the length and width across the toes but I was swimming in the heel. I really wanted to find another brand besides Vaneli that would work for my narrow AA foot but unfortunately, it is not Naturalizer.

The shoe is beautiful but it was too tight at the front part of shoe, I wear a 8WW (2E) and this was a 2EE but was too tight for me. Maybe the cut of the front is too high up for my foot.

Beautiful shoe, but doesn't fit like even a 9.5 AA. Though I'm a 9.5 AAA, I have a few 9.5 AA shoes that fit closer and tighter and feel secure on my feet. Honestly, I've NEVER been fortunate with Naturalizer in the fit department, but I wanted to give them a try because they are so beautiful. Will be returning.

loved the shoe, but too large and wide. I usually take an 8 n but this one was wrong size.

The Extra-Wides are still not very wide, and by the time I found a size that fit my toes, my narrower heels fell out and the heels were too high to walk in comfortably. I've tried multiple Naturalizers, and the issue is the same ever time: despite their descriptions, they just aren't very wide. Decent quality, but better for small feet.

It didn’t feel good on my foot. The toe bed was too narrow.

WOW! These are PAINFULLLLLLLLLL. I've always bought 5.5 (regular width) in heels but these hurt my feet like I've never before. I was going to return them and purchase them in a wide but they are out of stock so I'm stuck walking around with feet that feel like they're going to fall off. I'm going to purchase another pair and when those arrive I'll be sending these back. I tried on multiple Naturalizer shoes and was never very impressed.

These shoes were my #2 choice in my quest for a 2" block heel pump for this upcoming season. I had reservations about their appearance from the images shown on the Zappos website, but the great reviews and promise of a roomy, comfortable fit convinced me that these could work. When they arrived, I found them as visually unappealing in person as I did on the website. The heels are large and clunky to the point they seem out of proportion to the rest of the shoe. The throat/toe box of the shoe is far too low for me-- it ended just barely above my toes at the highest point, almost at the "toe cleavage" point, which I really don't like and is not comfortable for me. I found them snug in terms of width and while they probably would have stretched and broken in with wear, I don't care for their styling and need these to be comfortable out of the box. So back they go while my search continues. As for positives, the leather is nice and soft and the foot bed is well-padded and looks very comfortable. If you like the way these look and the fit suits you, I can see how these shoes could be winners. They just don't work for me.

Shoes are just ok. Not really comfortable, but not hurting as much as the ones I tried before.

I was really hoping these shoes would work to wear to the office, but they were too narrow and tight at the front of the shoe near the ball of my foot. Otherwise, the shoe offers moderate arch support, which is important to me, as I suffer from plantar fasciitis. Thankfully, returns are a breeze with Zappos!

I ordered a EE, but it is extremely narrow. This show is stiff an uncomfortable.

Not the color advertised. Much more of a nude color tan color vs. a blush nude. The foot bed was comfortable but very stiff and could tell it was going to be uncomfortable.

If you wear WW be warned that this WW felt like a D, if that. Not WW and did not feel like it would "give". #DemandTruthInSizing

Looks pink right, and it is completely beige. Returning. Disappointed.

Absolutely could not wear this shoe. My foot was jammed up against the front of the shoe while there was still a little room behind my heel. The shoe was definitely the right size, but there was no way for my foot to stay in proper position. Perhaps the issue was the heel height?

So disappointed in the width. I ordered the WW shoe and these shoes fit no way close to being WW shoe. If they would have fit like a WW shoe, the comfort and the style would have been great! Please, Naturalizer, do not leave those of us w/ extra wide feet with no options in your shoe line!!

I really liked the look but it cuts across the ball of your foot and is not comfortable then. If it just came up a little higher on my foot it would have been perfect.