Customer Reviews Naturalizer Whitney

I ordered a W pair of these in the blue "ink" suede. A gorgeous shoe but still too tight for bunion width in the toe box and the heel is too high for me.

I wanted to love these but my long narrow foot with high arch could not keep these on my feet. Sorry they are going back

Loved the style of this pump but I have a narrow foot and heel and I walked right out of the narrow size. Sadly I will be returning them.

These run big. The 11 seemed a whole size bigger. Possibly a comfortable shoe but I am not crazy about the round toe once I tried on. Heel Hight is what I would say perfect for some one tall like me. A little heel to look nice with clothes but not too high.

This is an attractive shoe. Nice deep navy color. Very comfortable cushioning inside. My problem was the back of the shoe didn't touch my heel; it looked like I was a little girl standing in my Mom's shoes! The toe box area fit fine so I couldn't go any smaller. They're going back.

too small, too tight, too narrow - and not as nice in person as they are in the photo (IMO)

Felt much more narrow than 2 e. Very sad, about the fit.

The color name was turtle dove online. The color name on the box is grey. Turtle dove looked like a pink/taupe color. The grey is a grey/taupe. It wasn't what I wanted. I kept a black pair and a taupe pair.

Cute and super comfy, but not really navy blue. Wish they were darker.

The shoes i received were not as pictured. The shoes I received were exactly like another pair I have called the "Donelle" WHILE THE SHOE IS NOT THE STYLE I ORDERED, THEY WERE VERY NICE SHOES, WHICH IS WHY THEY ONLY GET 3 STARS.

the blue is much brighter than it appears in the photo online--too bright to go with navy!

Quite comfortable, even in bare feet, but will be returning due to creaking sound these shoes make with every step on bare feet. I ordered Turtle Dove color, which looked like a light mauve on screen. The box I received was labeled Grey leather, and the shoes looked beige.

I'd pair these with some androgynous trousers. As a special size customer, I'm so disappointed in Naturalizer. I bought two pairs of their WW (E) shoes in one order and both were too narrow. On the bad advice of another review, I bought this shoe half a size larger, which was absolutely unnecessary. It has a nice square toe, but still strangled my baby toe. Definitely go half width up in this shoe. I personally will avoid this brand in the future. SAS has fab sandals, but I need a pump for interviews.

These shoes are extremely comfortable, BUT! I wear a size 9, and have for years. I never need to get another size, regardless of the the type of shoe. This shoe in a size 9 had a full inch of space at the heel on me and my feet completely slip out of them. The large heel is neat looking, but the super rounded toe looked a little "old lady" to me.

I normally wear an 8 1/2 Narrow. However, because Naturalizer usually runs 1/2 size large, I ordered an 8 N. Still at least 1/2 size too big. My foot won't stay in these shoes for anything. Sending them back.

These shoes looked like I was a little girl stepping into her mother's shoes. They were boats and way too large! I am a 7.5 N and that is what the shoe and box said. However, they felt like 10 M or W.

As soon as I put it on to try it, I knew it that it would hurt my feet. I felt right away that it would be uncomfortable even without walking around with it. I am returning this in exchange for another brand.

I really wanted to love this show. I loved everything about them except they are anything but narrow. My foot slid down in the toe and I walked right out of them. Very disappointing.

My normal 7N was too large and way too wide in the heels. Also, something about the construction made them seem cheaply made - like they would not last long. Back they went.

I had to return the shoe because it was to big.