Customer Reviews Naturalizer Whitney

These shoes seemed like they would be comfortable, but they were just too narrow. I typically wear a 6.5-7 WW, and I ordered a 7WW in these.

9M is my usual size in most supportive, well designed shoes; I have an average width foot. I tried both the 9M and 9W. 9M was too tight in the toes and even very slightly big; the 9W fit better but slipped off my feet. I tried the Cookie Dough Suede 9W and Taupe 9M. I hope these work for someone else. Returning. Oh, and thank you reviewer that advised ordering a 1/2 down and in W. I shoulda listened to ya!

Shoe ran long - felt like a full size larger. Also the heel was a little to high for me due to knee replacements and spine surgery. They will be returned.

In the regular width, the length of my usual 7 fit fine, but the toe felt narrow. Based on reviews, I also ordered the 61/2 regular (I am not usually a wide), but this was too short even though the toe felt better. The 7 wide was too long, but the toe felt better. So, if ordering wide, size down 1/2 size; if regular width, regular size should be fine, but note that it does run narrow in regular.

These seemed to run pretty large. The almond toe is usually a good match for me, but here, they actually lifted up away from my foot which was strange. With the heel and the fit of the toe, they made my feet look gigantic. My husband absolutely hated them.

I ordered this shoe in a 9 1/2W however I had to return it due to it being too narrow. It definitely didn't fit like a Wide shoe. I may consider ordering a WW which I've never needed to do before. It is a very nice looking shoe.

These are beautiful shoes. A rich red suede. But I had to return because they were too wide for a M for me.

I ordered the size I normally wear and they felt tight across the toe and a 1/2 size to short. Great looking shoe otherwise. Hated that I had to return them.

This shoe is super cute, and well made. Unfortunately, 6.5 does not come in wide, and 7W was too big for me. Too bad, will have to keep looking for a cute and comfortable work shoe.

These are super cute and comfy but after one wear there is some screw or pin that came loose inside the heel and it makes a jingling noise when I walk. Very annoying and unfortunately I’m out of the country with these as my only business appropriate shoes...

Attractive and fit true to size, but extremely stiff. I could not bend my foot while wearing them.

I own 2 other pairs of this shoe and they fit great. Unfortunately the suede seems to run a bit wider. The color is not flattering.

Liked the style, but runs about 1 size too large.

The look of these shoes is spot on classic. The heel is perfect height for work or travel. My issue was with the toebox, it is more narrow than I could take and I have always worn a medium width. Also, the lack of arch support resulted in pressure in the ball of the foot. I believe the quality to be good, so if you have a narrow toebox these are a great buy.

These are sized correctly, cute and pretty comfortable but I wanted a little higher stacked heel so back they went!

pretty but hurt were them for a minute

These were cute shoes but I did not like how shallow they felt. They seemed short around the toe area and whole foot. Too bad!

Pros: super stylish with dress pants. Cons: * a smidge wider than normal dress shoes in my size. * toes felt pinched * Zero arch support * zero cushioning (feet were killing me at the end of the day)

I love this shoe - I have a pair of Navy Suede ones that are so comfortable, but this shoe was too narrow so I have to return.

These shoes looked perfect but squeezed my little toe too much. I have a narrow foot but ordered the Medium width. I cannot wear these shoes.

The right shoe was strangely bent in the box when I received it. The shoe was permanently creased on the bend.

I have bunions and was hopeful that these would work for me after reading other reviews. I always have a hard time finding any kind of dress shoe because I have narrow feet except for the bunions. I will say that the cushioning in the sole is nice!

Cute. Comfortable. But they squeeked when I walked!