Customer Reviews OluKai Pehuea Leather

Too small. Uncomfortable for my bunions and high arch. Liked the fox color.

I am usually a 38 EU, and that is what I ordered, but these are a bit long. They are fine in the width. I am debating trying a 7.5, but think that might be too small. I like the look and the support is enough for me. I like Alegria and Taos, if that helps anyone. I would also do Vionic, but they never seem to fit right. The reason for only three stars is that I don't know if I like the folding heel. Because it folds, it offers no stability at all. I had to use my finger like a shoe horn. Once on, maybe because they are a bit big, my heel comes up quite a bit and again, the lack of structure in the heel caused me to "squish" the heel down a couple of times. I noticed most of their shoes have this set up.... it's kind of strange to me.

I love the look even more in person than on the screen. They ran small though, otherwise they seem like they would be comfortable.

I've been wearing the canvas style all summer and knew it was time to put them away but wanted something similar for the fall / winter. I ordered the leather. The size is perfect as far as length but the width at the toe box is a tad small. I hoping it will stretch the more I wear them. I don't think I'll have any issues other than my bunions hurting at the end of the day.

These fit tighter than the fabric version. The leather did not stretch out to make them comfortable after wearing them for a bit.

Nice comfortable insert but was a little high - didn't leave much room for socks. Also runs .5 size small

I had been very excited about these shoes & ordered up a size based on overwhelming opinion these shoes run small. They were too big, even after I put in double orthotics & discovered my usual size would have been fine. However, their main attraction to me had been the ability to wear them with the heel down as slip ons but I discovered the design left one with a pointy part that was uncomfortable & annoying to wear the shoe that way. Wish they designed the woman's shoe with a sole dyed to match the uppers like the men's walking shoe. It is a better look.

Looked very promising - but they are sliding off when I walk (8.5, medium to narrow foot). Going back.

I really wanted to like these shoes, but they just don't fit right and had to return. They are very tight across the top and a tad narrow and going a size up didn't help. I have a pair of OluKai men's shoes that fit better.

I can't remember how they fit but I didn't like the leather - didn't seem like they would breathe and I think they would have been too hot for summer wear

This shoe fit a bit snug for my usual size and was very stiff. The quality of the leather is nicee but a bit hard. The style looks good and the color was true to the picture. I did not like the slipper back as it was not easy to put the shoe on without the back folding down. Great if you want the style but I did not. Will return these as I want a softer, easy to slip on shoe.

I loved the style of these, but unfortunately the vamp was much too tight for my high-ish instep. Otherwise, they fit perfectly. I feel like the leather may have stretched enough over time, but unfortunately, I didn't want to take the risk and not be able to return worn shoes. I loved the style of these so much and wish they had worked for me.

Ordered size 9 and they are too large, but not enough arch support for me anyway, so not planning to try a smaller size. They make my not tiny foot look huge!

Stiff and too tight across the ball of the foot for me. Like the look.

I love OluKai and have Sandals from them which are my favorite! I was so excited to find these and was sure I would keep them for years to come. However, I was very disappointed in the color. I ordered the clay expecting a grey color which is what they look like online. Nope clay is more a light sage green. So I returned them. They were VERY comfy and if they had been the color I wanted I would have kept them.

This shoe is very narrow. My feet are normal size but my daughter who wears the same size has really narrow feet and it felt too snug for her.

I was excited for these and loved the look but they were stiff, uncomfortable, tight, and the footbed was just awful. I am measured at a size 4.5 but normally wear size 5. These were very snug and other slip-ons from this brand are usually too large. Returning.

I have a couple Olukai shoes that I purchase in Hawaii but these feel really stiff and the tanning on the leather is very uneven.

These look so cheap in person. Maybe if they were $50 I'd keep them, but $100?! No way, these do not feel that quality at all.

I love the way the shoe looked, but unfortunately I have to return them because the sizing was all off. I normally wear an 11, and I could not even get the shoe on. Unfortunately, 11 is the largest size they carry so I am out of luck. I did not feel like a true 11 though.

I tried a 7.5 and 8 because I never seem to be the same across brands. The 8 was very large, the 7.5 maybe a little small depending on type of sock, or no sock. I could work with it in that size. It is mostly cute, and has ok arch support for what I would need at work. However, the heel is a deal breaker. The "fold down" option to make it a slide is awful. It looks strange in person, and is hard to put on. Once on, it has no structure and constantly slid down my heel. Sending back. Thanks, Zappos for making returns easy.

So disappointed my normal size 9 does not fit. Will be returning my shoes

I didn't notice that these shoes are totally unlined in the heel area. They just didn't feel good on my ankles/heels. The leather isn't that soft, and if it was soft enough it wouldn't provide any support at all. So I'm returning them.

These ran very small on me. I ordered a half size up (from 9 to 9.5) in a wide because I have wide feet and I could barely get them on my feet, once on they were extremely tight. I don't think going up to a 10 would matter because I needed more room in the width.

This is the second pair of OluKai Pehuea Leather shoes that I have owned. I bought my first pair after having several pairs of OluKai flipflops -- which were and are wonderful. My first pair of Pehuea leather shoes were almost perfect -- although I had to size up a whole size to get a good fit. They were comfortable, versatile, and had excellent arch support. I viewed them as "expensive and worth it", so I eagerly ordered a second pair. My experience with my first pair was so wonderful that I wore the second pair outside without testing them at home. Big Mistake. I don't know if the second pair is narrower or if they're finished -- or not finished -- differently from the first pair, but I ended up with blisters on both feet (inside edge of one big toe and at the widest part of my foot below the other big toe.) Once the blisters healed, I tried them again -- same problem. I could try wearing them with socks -- but that defeats the purpose. At this point, my versatile summer shoes are unwearable . Lesson learned: Each pair of shoes might be different. Manufacturing standards might change. Even my feet might change. From now on, I'll devote much more time to wearing each and every pair of shoes I buy indoors -- appreciating with every step Zappos's generous return policy.