Customer Reviews OluKai Pehuea Leather

I purchased the size I would normally buy in tennis shoes first, but it was too big. Going down a size, the fit seemed mostly right on, but unfortunately my forefoot felt slightly constricted while my heels slipped out with each step. I debated trying to switch out insoles, add heel pads, etc...but ultimately returned. The price was high for me to not feel like they are a sure thing. They felt like they would be comfortable shoes for the right foot and they were so cute. I loved the clay color and was sad they didn't work.

Narrower than expected. Tight on the top of foot. Doesn't breathe very well. I LOVE the look of these, so I'm going to keep them and they're comfortable and high-quality enough that I know they'll break in.

Love Olukai yet these shoes didn’t work for me. They rubbed my baby toes too much. I own the same style in canvas and mesh and love them. I think for my feet the leather is too restrictive.

I really loved the look of these, they are very well made looking in person, the details are sharp and I like the seaming on them. The soles are more of a cream than white if that matters to you. My main problem was that they were obviously too large even though I ordered my normal size. I ended up returning them.

I tried the fabric OluKai shoes and loved the comfort but wasn't a fan of the look. I liked the look of the leather but not nearly as soft and comfortable as the fabric. Oh well...returned

These are very cute shoes, but if you have a wider foot just know you'll have to size up I went up a half size and they fit but they are also a little long now. I love OluKai sandals because they look so nice and hope that these wear as well as my sandals.

Have had these for a while now and they are my every day shoe. They are cute and go with everything, best part is they are so easy to slip on when running out of the house. The back bends inward so you can just slip them on and off when you just need to run outside for a minute without damaging the shoe. Only problem is they are not breathable at all, so wear without socks and they do eventually make your feet stink!

Nice shoe, but liked the leather styles better for all season wear.

I normally way a 6.5 to 7 B shoe.--7.5 in athletic footwear. Based on reviews, I ordered a 7.5 and a 7. The 7.5 was too large, but the 7 was uncomfortably narrow. I returned them both. The shoe is nice looking and it seemed well made so it was simply a matter of not fitting my feet properly.

I originally purchased these shoes in a 9, but I could not even get my feet in them at all and had to exchange for a full size up. But, once I was in the 10 I really liked the shoes. They seem well constructed and like they are going to last for a long time. I like that the outsole is not bright white but more of an off-white instead. The leather is thick and has a nice color and texture. After swapping in better insoles and breaking them in for a few days I can say they are very comfortable. I would highly recommend these shoes to a person with narrow feet. If your feet are really wide, I would get another shoe. Having to go a whole size up was ok for me as I don't mind a little extra room for my toes, but I don't think it would work for everyone.

LOVE!

I had high hopes for these as I've never purchased OluKai and they came highly recommended. I typically wear an 8 or 8.5, and these (in an 8.5) were very short. I didn't feel like they had great arch support. Unfortunately, they are going back.

I love the shoes but I couldn't find size that fits! I ordered sz 9 my usual size and the shoes were falling off my feet. Ordered 8.5 and it was too small. Couldn't find one that works. Other colors fit different!

These are beautiful, but something was wrong with the footbed in the left shoe. Returning and trying again.

These are super cute. For most people, this would be a 5 star shoe. These have decent arch support, but I need a lot. Wish they had a bit more arch support and cushion, but my feet are pickier than most!

I loved the look of this shoe; I was debating between this and another pair that has slightly more support in the footbed. I think it would have been a good choice, but the other shoe won out, so this one went back. But, the black upper has a subtle design that is slightly more interesting than a plain black shoe. Seems like a great little sneaker for everyday wear.

This is a nice, comfortable, casual shoe. The texture on the leather gives it a little more interest, which I liked. The arch support is really good, as per OluKai's standard, though not the most supportive I've seen from their other styles. It should work well with jeans and I'm hoping provide some relief for plantar fasciitis. It was true to size and width. Toe box is fairly roomy. My feet aren't quite narrow and not quite medium width and this seems like it will work pretty well.

I really loved opening the box and seeing these great shoes, and the subtle leather pattern with the color is perfect. BUT, they're going back, because while the right shoe fits my size 9 foot to a "T", the left shoe felt almost a half-size too large and slipped on my heel when I walked in them. Too bad, so sad!

These are a beautiful variation of the "vans" type leather slip on with a thick rubber sole. Very nice details and good quality leather. They look expensive and nice. Good arch support, but they seem to run small. The leather is soft, so hopefully, they will stretch a litle. Luckily, I had ordered a 1/2 size larger because I have wide feet and they fit comfortably.

This shoe is beautiful in Clay leather. I wanted to keep it, but the toe box is just slightly narrow so the inside of my big toe rubs against the shoe. Wah. I have a Medium width foot. I normally wear size 8, and bought these in 8.5. I think an 8 would have been just a tiny bit too small. Style-wise, it can't be beat. A classier version than Vans (which does have its' place sometimes, too) and it just looks a bit sleek.

So. I had two of these pairs of shoes for a few years and they have been my absolute favorite shoe. Both pairs are starting to show their wear and I decided I wanted to replace them w the same exact style bc I love them so much. Sadly, it seems Olukai is no longer making this exact shoe. When I saw this last pair pop up - it must have been a return on an older set of shoes - I was pumped. But now that I have them, I am wondering is the manufacturing has changed or if they are using cheaper materials or both?? These shoes fit the same in terms of width and length, the materials feel stiff and like they will require a blistered break-in period. My other shoes never required this. So I think maybe they are using cheaper leather now?? I'm going to keep them with the hope of breaking them in, but I shouldn't have to with a $100 pair of shoes. Harrumph.

i really wanted to love these shoes, but: i am a perfect size 9 in all brands. the 9 M felt a little tight even w the heel down. couldn't wear w anklets or socks. when the heel was down, there were uncomfortable prongs of leather that stuck into both sides of my foot... so back to hawaii they go.

Love the look but they slip completely off my heel when I walk. Wasn’t sure if the lava rock color would be gray or black. It’s a matte black. Very nice. Wish I could have kept these.

My main problem with these is that I really need a 10.5. 10 are too small and narrow and the 11 are too big. The leather was pretty stiff on the backs as well. Nice quality shoe though and good arch support.

Felt true to size, nice clean lines. The sole is very stiff and does not bend. Returned because it was too big and stiff. I ordered a 6 hoping it might fit my 5.5 feet.