Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip-On

I purchased these shoes about a month ago and I am So pleased... they are true to size and comfortable right out of the box. I plan to purchase more colors.

THESE SHOES ARE THE BEST!! I bought these shoes because I was looking for a black flat and thought I'd give them a try( even though they were pricey) and I couldnt be happier. SO comfortable, stylish and well made. So much so that I've just ordered my second pair. they do run slightly smaller even with narrow feet and normal stretching of the leather.

Very happy with this purchase. The shoes are comfortable, have nice arch support, and I love the color (mine are gray).

I saw these on a girl in a cafe and I needed to know what they were. I have never regretted buying them for a second, despite the price tag. They are unbelievably comfortable, and go with so many different things. They are perfect for walking all day, traveling light, anything.

Beautiful and comfortable. I think I will buy another pair.

I bought my first pair of Melanie flats a month ago, loved them so much bought a pair in every color...my new favorite !

This shoe was comfortable from day one. There was no break-in period. I typically wear between a 9-9.5 and I ordered the 9.5 for a perfect fit. The leather feels as though it will stretch a little over time. Of course it is Frye quality and looks fantastic. I absolutely love it. It wouldn't hurt my feelings to have one in every color.

The Melanie Slip-On shoes are true to size and very comfortable! The green color is quite rich and vibrant ~ love them!

Bought these for my Europe trip. They were a little tight on my big toe but the leather does stretch and now they fit perfect. I learned in Italy that I have been buying my shoes way too big and need to buy them snug and let my feet mold them. All my shoes end up being way too big.

The Melanie Slip-On shoes are true to size and very comfortable! The green color is quite rich and vibrant ~ love them!

I bought these yesterday and headed to the streets of NYC to tour while on vacation. They look so stylish with my walking shorts, skirts & my new denim shirt dress. So much nicer than my tennis shoes & the longer I have them on, the softer the leather feels. I'm in Love!

Very comfortable and very well made! I am very happy with the on line services.

I bought this after a friend recommended them. I normally hate flats because they make my feet hurt - these are so comfortable. Great support and cushioning. Plus they look beautiful.

I bought a pair in April and bought a second pair in May! Love them! They look great for casual wear and are so comfortable!

I have them in two colors & would get more! Great true to size shoes & can walk in them all day:-)

I bought the Melanie slip on shoes a week ago. Love them! I walked all over San Francisco wearing them--so comfortable. They mold right to your feet. I did however go up a half size to allow more room in the toe box.

I haven't stopped wearing these since they arrived! Perfect every day shoes that are light, comfortable, and supportive!

The most comfortable shoes I've ever owned. After reading the reviews saying they were narrow in the toe I decided to take my chances and I'm glad I did. They mold to your foot like a second skin. They are pretty narrow but not uncomfortably so.

These shoes were very well made and extremely comfortable from the first time I put them on. I have several pair of Frye's shoes and love them for the comfort also.

Bought these babies to sight-see in Greece and myriad pre-departure errands. Looking for something that was fail-safe-cumfy, but also smart enough not to detract from stylish outfits. These will do nicely. With a narrowed-toe that distinguishing them from clunkier sneaks, I feared they might pinch, but with very, very little break in around the house and they are already cloud-soft on my feet. They run true-to-size, but don't have as wide a toe box as a traditional sneaker, so if you don't have narrow feet, consider going up a half size. I got the "grey" which has quite a bit of mauve-y to it. Quite attractive: neutral, but not boring and can be worn with dark leggings, jeans, or white pants. I can see them complimenting a sundress as well. Like all Frye products, the materials and construction are quality. The leather in the upper looks up to long use, the footbed is padded, and the sole grip-y. These are lightweight, compared to, say, running shoes. Great for restricted-weight luggage!

Bought these babies to sight-see in Greece and myriad pre-departure errands. Looking for something that was fail-safe-cumfy, but also smart enough not to detract from stylish outfits. These will do nicely. With a narrowed-toe that distinguishing them from clunkier sneaks, I feared they might pinch, but with very, very little break in around the house and they are already cloud-soft on my feet. They run true-to-size, but don't have as wide a toe box as a traditional sneaker, so if you don't have narrow feet, consider going up a half size. I got the "grey" which has quite a bit of mauve-y to it. Quite attractive: neutral, but not boring and can be worn with dark leggings, jeans, or white pants. I can see them complimenting a sundress as well. Like all Frye products, the materials and construction are quality. The leather in the upper looks up to long use, the footbed is padded, and the sole grip-y. These are lightweight, compared to, say, running shoes. Great for restricted-weight luggage!

I bought two pairs this summer and wore the black a lot so just to be on the safe side I actually bought another pair in black. I hope they continue to carry this style since I am sure I will need to buy more in the future!

I purchased two pairs of these shoes, in black and tan. They are the most comfortable shoe I have ever owned. I spent a week in New York in these shoes and my feet felt perfect. I just purchased another pair.

Just got these in Coral, and they are beautiful! The leather is very soft with natural high and low tones of color. True to size, very comfortable walking shoes after just breaking them in one day. Smooth leather on the inside feels great. Cute with everything! Thinking about another color already!

Extremely comfortable. I love the distressed leather look! Run true to size. I will definitely purchase more shoes by Frye!