Customer Reviews J. Renee Soncino

I ordered 3 pairs of these shoes and each fit differently. The 3rd pair received were the best fit, BUT they had CLEARLY been worn, so I am returning them. Very disappointed that 1) a buyer would return worn shoes and 2) that Zappos would re-sell them at full price. In spite of the different fit per pair, they are lovely shoes - perfect for a special occasion. And they are very comfortable and stable to walk/dance in with the lower heel and secure ankle straps.

Nice looking shoes but smaller and narrower than expected. I'm returning these because they just don't fit right.

Really nice looking and comfortable dress shoe but it runs short! My heel hung off the back by a smidgen - not a good look for sandals. The heel height is perfect! I love these shoes and would've purchased another color if it fit. Very sad to have to return.

The shoe is beautiful but unfortunately the ankle and toe strap were too loose for my narrow foot.

The ankle strap did not work for me--I have very thin ankles. One shoe kept slipping off. Very pretty style and over was comfortable but did not work for me. Sent it back.

Ordered a size up as recommended. TOO big! :( Don't have next size down

I ordered a size up as recommended but they were too big. Unable to get them in the next size down :(

I am going to exchange this shoe for a half size larger. I always wear size 10, but on this shoe my heel hung over the back just a bit. Thankfully, it comes in 10 and a half. It is an attractive shoe and I may get it in another color as well.

This shoe is a young woman's game, for sure. I am in my 50s and found it hard to walk on the slender heel, not to mention the very weird wrapping strap. There wasn't much support through the ankle at all. It's a beautiful shoe, and would be great for someone used to walking in more slender heels or in slides. I need chunkier heels and a more supportive strap.

I have ordered J Renee shoes in the past but have always returned them. I give these a five for style and a two for fit. . Her shoes are very uncomfortable. I ordered a narrow in these and they are too wide. The strap is also too loose at the ankle. In the future, I will not even look at this brand of shoe. Too bad.

I bought and reviewed favorably these soncinos last fall; black suede. Recently, when nude nappa appeared among the choices, I acted quickly. I bought them again - one size down from my usual 9 to an 8.5 for the open toe - and I'm glad to have had the opportunity. The size down might not be necessary for everyone. Great shoe for sure-footed walking and for caution-to-the-wind dancing! Yes, there are better looking shoes out there but none so perfect for dancing.

These are so cute and comfortable! Unfortunately, because of the design of the strap, the foot slides out the back of the shoe with every step unless you grip your toes. There is no way you could dance or walk any distance in these shoes. I'm so sad I had to return them!

Photo was great but real life not the quality I wanted

Good quality

A very beautiful pair of shoes but they were too wide on the ankles. Adding extra holes in the straps would not have made them fit any better.

Wanted to like these sandals, but as others have stated, the ankle strap is way too big. I would need another hole about 1/2 an inch from the last one. Then the strap would stick out and look unattractive. The shoes have a few sequins on the top of the toe strap where non were shown in pictures and the "ribbon effect" was not evenly spaced on the outer side of the toe strap on both shoes. One had way less of the "ribbon". The bottom did have some nice padding for comfort and the heel height was about 2 inches, as described. Overall, just didn't care for these so they will be going back.

Cute shoe, but not for me. The fit was tight and heel wobbled for me. Thank you Zappos for allowing me to try.

The shoes are very feminine and pretty. The strap that wraps around the ankle has too much give and didn’t lay flat on my skin. I had to return the shoes.

The physics don't work. Very difficult to walk in because they don't hold the shoe to your foot securely.

These are lovely shoes so I am very disappointed that they are too short! I wear a 7 1/2 - 8. In heels, usually, the 7.5 because my foot is narrow and flat. The smaller size allows my (nonexistent) arch are to fall onto the right place (no gapping from heel to forefoot) and the front to prevent me from sliding forward and out of the shoe. I ordered the size 8 in these. I am shocked that they are too short and a bit wide. My heel stuck out over the back as well as my toes hung over the front ever so slightly. The color is gorgeous! A light pewter textured soft leather. Hardly any padding under the metatarsal and I expected a bit more since they are so costly! I really really wish they could have worked out because they work with my dress so well!

For being a wide shoe, it’s not all that wide. The ankle strap on one of shoes is shorter than the other side. They’re moderately comfortable. But they are darn cute shoes!

Very pretty shoe that looked nice on the foot - until I tried to walk in it. The floating ankle strap design did not hold my foot stable at all - it kept sliding around and lifting up every time I took a step. Also seems to run a bit small - I am always a 7 1/2, ordered my normal size but probably could have sized up a half size. I regretfully had to send it back.

Great looking shoe but for a wide shoe the edges of the strap that goes over the top of the foot cuts in badly. Feels much narrower than marked I usually would wear a 10 W which is what I ordered but it still felt too narrow. I would have kept them if the pinch wasn't so much!!

Pretty shoe but the blue is royal not navy.

Loved the look of this sandal. Really wanted it to work but very uncomfortable across my wide feet.