Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Waterproof XC4® Stanton Panel Toe Slip-On

This pair of shoes was not consistent with the sizing of another pair of J&M dress shoes that I have owned and loved for 10+ years. Therefore, I had to exchange the new pair after I received them for the correct (smaller) size. It's neat that you can remove an insert to make room for a wider foot, which I had to do, but then I lost some of the comfort with the extra cushioning taken out, which is why I am rating these 4/5 stars. These dress shoes look nice and seem like they'll be durable, and it's already come in handy that they are water resistant as I sometimes am working outdoors.

Nice fit and looks . If these hold up as good as they look and feel they are a winner. They will not be an everyday wear shoe so I'm expecting them to last. Happy with this purchase so far!

The style of shoe is what we were looking for but the fit was way too oversized. Had to return and will try a different size.

First quality shoe in awhile after wearing other brands to work for years, and I'm happy with them. One star missing bc it's double the price of other brands. Just sad you have to spend so much for quality

A snug fit but seems well made. I do miss a previous shoe that was made in Brazil, though.

Quick Arrival and Easy Returns. Shoe was comfortable but required small amount of break-in.

I fly for Southwest Airlines, and really enjoy this shoe. Good looking, and holds a nice shine, and most importantly, comfortable.

This a great shoe. One of the most comfortable shoes I've worn. They fit my feet great. Normally shows are to narrow but not these. If I was to complain about anything is the soles are on the hard side and makes the shoes a little noisy when walking on hard floors. Also I do have to use a shoe horn to get the shoes on. Another plus is they are extremely stylish.

Been wearing the general style for a few years now and just went back for another pair. Have in black and brown. Over 2 years of consistent use the fit felt too loose so I went for a new pair. Excellent buy

A little narrow when one has bunions. When I removed the first padding, I lost the comfort feeling because there is no more cushion.

Comfy and good looking

Great shoe. Only improvement would be better arch support. My favorite shoe was the Matthews, but it is no longer available. That is my biggest complaint about J-M. When I finally find one I like, I will buy 2-3 pair, but within a short time, it is no longer manufactured.

Thank You !

foot does not fit or slide into shoe, not enough flexibility where foot enters upper part of shoe. very disappointing. i wanted and needed this waterproof shoe. very difficult, almost impossible entry and exit

Nice fit

Have worn these for a little over two years now in all sorts of weather, and they remain in great shape. While not the most stylish shoes in my closet, they have become one of my favorites because of comfort and durability. I will probably reorder these - if the first ones ever wear out....

Very comfortable shoe to walk. Would have like them to be more stylish.

A little heavier than expected but still pretty flexible. Could use some memory foam under the met heads.

Good service

Your over the calf sock selections use to be a lot better. Not as stylish and limited selection especially at stores.